What is inside the Made By Mitchell Mystery Box?

The contents are not disclosed before purchase. Each box is a surprise mix of Made By Mitchell products, so the exact items and shades vary.

Is the Mystery Box worth it?

It is a low-cost way to try several brand products. Whether it pays off depends on how much of the line you already own and whether you like bold shades.

Can I choose the products or shades?

No. The box is sold as a surprise, with no selection of items, shades or product types.

Will I get duplicate products?

Duplicates are possible, especially if you already own many Made By Mitchell items. The brand does not guarantee that every box is different.

It works well as a gift for someone who enjoys makeup surprises and colorful shades. Check that they like the brand first, since the contents cannot be chosen.

Where is the Made By Mitchell Mystery Box cheapest?

At BEAUTY BAY, for $39.45, 55% off, as of our latest check.

Is the Made By Mitchell Mystery Box at its lowest price?

Yes: $39.45 is the lowest price we've seen for it since October 30.

What do buyers say about the Made By Mitchell Mystery Box?

Rated 4.7 out of 5 from 10 ratings.

Made By Mitchell Mystery Box

Best price now

$39.45at BEAUTY BAYChecked 6 h ago

Deal: 55% off at BEAUTY BAY →

Prices are checked against each store and labelled with when.

Visit BEAUTY BAY

Made By Mitchell Mystery Box

Best price now

$39.45at BEAUTY BAYChecked 6 h ago

Deal: 55% off at BEAUTY BAY →

Prices are checked against each store and labelled with when.

Visit BEAUTY BAY

Ask our agent about this product

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Price facts

Lowest price today: $39.45 at BEAUTY BAY (checked Nov 11, 2026).

Our take on the Made By Mitchell Mystery Box

The Made By Mitchell Mystery Box is a surprise bundle of cosmetics from the UK makeup brand known for its colorful palettes and bold pigments. The contents are not disclosed before purchase, so each box is a gamble on what shades and products you receive. It suits fans of the brand's high-pigment style and gift buyers who like a surprise. The trade-off against picking single items is that you cannot choose shades or product types, and repeats are possible for shoppers who already own much of the line.

Best forFans of Made By Mitchell who want to try products they would not pick themselvesMakeup lovers who enjoy colorful, high-pigment shadesGift buyers who want a ready-made surpriseShoppers comfortable with not knowing the exact contents

Pros

Low entry price for a bundle of brand products
Suits the brand's bold, colorful style
Works as a gift or a way to discover new items
Simple one-price purchase with no size or shade choices

Cons

Contents are unknown until the box arrives
No guarantee of specific products or shades
Duplicates are possible for shoppers who already own much of the line
Shades may not suit everyone's coloring

Made By Mitchell Mystery Box prices at every store

BEAUTY BAYNew
In stock
$39.45+ $15.00 shippingChecked 6 h ago
Visit BEAUTY BAY

Made By Mitchell Mystery Box price history

$39.45$39.45

Oct 30Nov 11

Lowest price we've seen: $39.45 on Oct 30 at BEAUTY BAY. Tracked across 1 store since Oct 30.

What reviewers say

4.7 / 510 ratings

Only a small number of ratings exist, and they are positive overall. Buyers describe the box as good value and fun to open.

What people mention

ValuePraisedBuyers say the box delivers more product than the price suggests.
Surprise factorPraisedOwners enjoy not knowing what is inside until it arrives.
Shade suitabilityMixedSome buyers find the shades do not match their coloring.
DuplicatesCriticisedFans who already own a lot of the line may receive repeats.

From BEAUTY BAY

A bag of six mystery makeup products
Packed with six Made By Mitchell products
Perfect as a treat for yourself or a gift
Cruelty free

Returns: Return items by post within 30 days of receipt; items must be unused, unopened and have original seals intact.
Shipping: Tracked delivery, 4-8 days post dispatch, deliveries Mon-Fri; free delivery available on orders over a threshold.
In the box: Six Made By Mitchell mystery makeup products

About the Made By Mitchell Mystery Box

A bag of six mystery makeup products.

Shake up your makeup collection with the Made By Mitchell Expect The Unexpected Mystery Box. Packed with six Made By Mitchell products worth £78, your for just £35. Perfect as a treat for yourself or a gift. Everyone loves a mystery!

- Cruelty free

Questions and answers

What is inside the Made By Mitchell Mystery Box?: The contents are not disclosed before purchase. Each box is a surprise mix of Made By Mitchell products, so the exact items and shades vary.
Is the Mystery Box worth it?: It is a low-cost way to try several brand products. Whether it pays off depends on how much of the line you already own and whether you like bold shades.
Can I choose the products or shades?: No. The box is sold as a surprise, with no selection of items, shades or product types.
Will I get duplicate products?: Duplicates are possible, especially if you already own many Made By Mitchell items. The brand does not guarantee that every box is different.
Is it a good gift?: It works well as a gift for someone who enjoys makeup surprises and colorful shades. Check that they like the brand first, since the contents cannot be chosen.
Where is the Made By Mitchell Mystery Box cheapest?: At BEAUTY BAY, for $39.45, 55% off, as of our latest check.
Is the Made By Mitchell Mystery Box at its lowest price?: Yes: $39.45 is the lowest price we've seen for it since October 30.
What do buyers say about the Made By Mitchell Mystery Box?: Rated 4.7 out of 5 from 10 ratings.

Stores we've priced the Made By Mitchell Mystery Box at

BEAUTY BAY deals and prices

More from Made By Mitchell

All Made By Mitchell deals and products →

Stores we've priced the Made By Mitchell Mystery Box at

BEAUTY BAY deals and prices

More from Made By Mitchell

All Made By Mitchell deals and products →