Does the Naturalizer Everly run true to size?

No. Buyers consistently report it runs large, and many size down a half size. If you are between sizes or have a narrow foot, try the smaller size first.

Is $49.99 a good price for this pump?

Yes. At $49.99 at Famous Footwear as of November 4, 2026, it is well under the usual $80–$110 range for this style. Six stores list it new, so compare before buying.

Is the heel really 2.25 inches?

Naturalizer states 2.25 inches, but some buyers say it measures higher. It is still a low, walkable heel, not a stiletto.

Can I wear these all day at work?

Most buyers say yes. The Contour+ footbed and low heel suit long days on your feet. If the heel slips, a heel grip or half insole helps, though some find inserts make the shoe tight.

What widths are available?

The Everly comes in an inclusive range of sizes and widths, including wide options. Check the specific listing for the width you need.

What comes in the box?

One pair of pumps. No extra insoles or shoe care items are included.

Where is the Naturalizer Everly Patent Leopard Print Pump cheapest?

At Famous Footwear, for $49.99, 55% off, as of our latest check.

What do buyers say about the Naturalizer Everly Patent Leopard Print Pump?

Rated 4.2 out of 5 from 445 ratings. Buyers like: Very comfortable, including as work heels; Beautiful leopard print that doesn't look cheap or too shiny; Perfect heel height. Common complaints: Runs large; heel slips off the foot; Shoe can be too big even in the correct size.