Are the Albany II boots actually waterproof?

The synthetic upper is waterproof and handles slush and light snow. Prolonged wet or deep slush can get through the seams over time, so they are not a rubber-boot substitute.

They have 200-gram insulation and a nylon lining, enough for freezing commutes and shoveling. They are not rated for extreme cold or long stationary time outdoors.

Do they fit true to size?

Fit reports vary, with some saying they run small and others large. If you wear thick socks, consider going up half a size, and try them on before relying on them.

How do they compare with Sorel or Kamik snow boots?

The Albany II is lighter and easier to get on thanks to the zipper, but Sorel and Kamik boots generally beat it on outsole grip and long-term waterproofing.

Can I wear them for hiking?

No. The TPR outsole and casual build suit pavement, driveways and packed trails. For real winter hikes, choose a boot with a lugged rubber outsole and a stiffer shank.