Does the Old Navy loafer mule fit true to size?

Reviews are split. Some buyers take their usual size, while others say it runs narrow or short and suggest sizing up if you are between sizes.

No. The upper is smooth faux leather, so it is soft and easy to clean but creases and scuffs more than genuine leather.

Can I wear it to the office?

It suits casual and smart-casual dress codes with trousers or jeans. The open heel and soft upper make it too casual for formal workplaces.

How does it compare with a closed penny loafer?

The mule version is easier to slip on and cooler for warm days, but it grips the heel less and can slide off when you walk fast.

One pair of shoes. No shoe bag or extra laces are included.

Is it good for all-day walking?

The cushioned insole helps for short trips, but the thin sole and backless fit give little support for long days on foot.

Where is the Old Navy Women's Loafer Mule Shoes cheapest?

At Old Navy, for $20.99, as of our latest check.

What do buyers say about the Old Navy Women's Loafer Mule Shoes?

Rated 3.5 out of 5 from 487 ratings.

Where can I buy the Old Navy Women's Loafer Mule Shoes?

4 stores we checked sell it, including eBay, Poshmark, Old Navy, DoorDash.

Old Navy Women's Loafer Mule Shoes

Best price now

$20.99at Old NavyChecked Nov 9

Compared across 5 stores. Prices are checked against each store and labelled with when.

Visit Old Navy

Old Navy Women's Loafer Mule Shoes

Best price now

$20.99at Old NavyChecked Nov 9

Compared across 5 stores. Prices are checked against each store and labelled with when.

Visit Old Navy

Old Navy discount code →

Ask our agent about this product

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Price facts

Last seen at $20.99 at Old Navy on Nov 9.
Checked at 5 stores.

Our take on the Old Navy Women's Loafer Mule Shoes

The Old Navy Women's Loafer Mule is a backless penny loafer in smooth faux leather, with a strap across the vamp and a cushioned insole. It is a casual, easy-on shoe meant for jeans, trousers and smart-casual outfits. Against leather loafers it trades durability for a soft, flexible upper and a low-key look. Owners like the slip-on convenience and the classic penny strap; the middling ratings point to fit and long-term wear as the weak spots.

Best forShoppers who want an easy slip-on for errands and casual daysWearers who prefer a backless mule over a closed loaferSmart-casual outfits with jeans or wide-leg trousersAnyone trying the loafer look without a leather shoe

Pros

Open heel makes it quick to slide on and off
Cushioned insole adds comfort for short wears
Classic penny-loafer strap gives a familiar look
Smooth faux leather wipes clean easily
Works with jeans, trousers and casual dresses

Cons

Faux leather can crease and scuff faster than real leather
Backless fit can slip off the heel when walking
Sizing runs inconsistent for some buyers
Thin sole offers little support for long days on foot

Old Navy Women's Loafer Mule Shoes prices at every store

eBayPre-owned
In stock
$4.50Checked Nov 9
Visit eBay
PoshmarkPre-owned
In stock
$11.00Checked Nov 9
Visit Poshmark
Old NavyNew
In stock
$20.99Checked Nov 9
Visit Old Navy
PoshmarkNew
In stock
$24.00Checked Nov 9
Visit Poshmark
eBayNew
Availability unknownReturns: Set by the eBay seller; the eBay Money Back Guarantee covers an item that doesn't arrive or isn't as described.
$49.99+ $8.85 shippingChecked Nov 9
Visit eBay
DoorDashNew
Out of stockSold by Old Navy
$34.99Checked Nov 9
Visit DoorDash

Store links may earn us a commission.

Old Navy Women's Loafer Mule Shoes price history

Lowest price we've seen: $20.99 on Nov 9 at Old Navy. Tracked across 3 stores since Nov 9.

What reviewers say

3.5 / 5487 ratings

Buyers rate the mule around the middle. They like the easy slip-on fit and the classic penny-loafer styling, but complain about sizing and how the faux leather holds up.

What people mention

FitMixedSome buyers find the mule true to size, while others say it runs narrow or short.
Slip-on easePraisedOwners like that the open heel makes the shoe quick to put on and take off.
MaterialCriticisedThe faux leather creases and scuffs sooner than buyers expect.
Heel slipCriticisedThe backless design lets the heel slide out, especially when walking quickly.
ComfortPraisedThe cushioned insole is comfortable for errands and short outings.

From Poshmark

Classic slip-on penny loafer mule in smooth faux leather
Cushioned insole for all-day comfort
Versatile style for casual and smart-casual wear
Strap at vamp
Open heel
Easy slip-on style

Sizes: 8
Materials: Smooth faux leather
Fit: Mule with open heel
Shipping: Posh Protect: Buyer Protection Policy — get your order as described or receive your money back
In the box: Shoes

About the Old Navy Women's Loafer Mule Shoes

These are women's slip-on penny loafer mules from Old Navy, made in smooth faux leather. They come in brown and have a strap across the vamp.

The mule design has an open heel, so the shoes slip on and off easily. A cushioned insole adds comfort. The style suits casual and smart-casual outfits.

Material: Smooth faux leather
Color: Brown
Style: Slip-on penny loafer mule
Fit: Mule with open heel
Design: Strap at vamp
Insole: Cushioned
Size: 8
Condition: New with tags
In the box: Shoes

Questions and answers

Does the Old Navy loafer mule fit true to size?: Reviews are split. Some buyers take their usual size, while others say it runs narrow or short and suggest sizing up if you are between sizes.
Is it real leather?: No. The upper is smooth faux leather, so it is soft and easy to clean but creases and scuffs more than genuine leather.
Can I wear it to the office?: It suits casual and smart-casual dress codes with trousers or jeans. The open heel and soft upper make it too casual for formal workplaces.
How does it compare with a closed penny loafer?: The mule version is easier to slip on and cooler for warm days, but it grips the heel less and can slide off when you walk fast.
What is in the box?: One pair of shoes. No shoe bag or extra laces are included.
Is it good for all-day walking?: The cushioned insole helps for short trips, but the thin sole and backless fit give little support for long days on foot.
Where is the Old Navy Women's Loafer Mule Shoes cheapest?: At Old Navy, for $20.99, as of our latest check.
What do buyers say about the Old Navy Women's Loafer Mule Shoes?: Rated 3.5 out of 5 from 487 ratings.
Where can I buy the Old Navy Women's Loafer Mule Shoes?: 4 stores we checked sell it, including eBay, Poshmark, Old Navy, DoorDash.