Is the Kaya 2 comfortable for all-day wear?

The kitten heel and cushioned footbed make it easier to wear for long stretches than a high heel. The pointed toe can still pinch if your feet are wide.

Does it run true to size?

It is generally listed as medium width, but the pointed toe runs narrow for some buyers. Try your usual size first and size up if you have wide feet.

Is it leather or faux leather?

It depends on the colorway: some are genuine leather and some are faux leather, and all have a leather lining and rubber outsole. Check the material listed for the color you pick.

What heel height is the kitten heel?

It is a low kitten heel, roughly 2 inches or less, meant for a subtle lift rather than height.

Is $42.66 a good price?

That is the only new price listed, $42.66 at Mercari as of November 7, 2026, so there is no recent range to judge it against. It is a low price for a Sam Edelman pump.

Where is the Sam Edelman Women's Kaya 2 Pump cheapest?

At Mercari, for $42.66, as of our latest check.

What do buyers say about the Sam Edelman Women's Kaya 2 Pump?

Rated 4.7 out of 5 from 17 ratings.

Where can I buy the Sam Edelman Women's Kaya 2 Pump?

3 stores we checked sell it, including Mercari, 6pm.com, Soles Unlimited.

Browse

Sam Edelman Women's Kaya 2 Pump

Best price now

$42.66at MercariObserved at 1:43 PM

Prices are checked against each store and labelled with when.

Visit Mercari

Sam Edelman Women's Kaya 2 Pump

Best price now

$42.66at MercariObserved at 1:43 PM

Prices are checked against each store and labelled with when.

Visit Mercari

Ask our agent about this product

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Our take on the Sam Edelman Women's Kaya 2 Pump

The Sam Edelman Kaya 2 is a women's pointed-toe kitten-heel pump with a bit detail across the vamp, a leather lining and a cushioned footbed. It comes in metallic silver and pink faux-leather and leather versions on a rubber outsole. The only new price listed is $42.66 at Mercari as of November 7, 2026, so there is no recent range to compare it against.

Best forShoppers who want a low kitten heel for work or eventsBuyers after a metallic silver pumpAnyone who prefers a pointed toe with a bit detailShoppers on a tight budget

Pros

Low kitten heel is easy to walk in for long days
Pointed toe and bit detail give a polished, dressy look
Leather lining and cushioned footbed add comfort
Rubber outsole gives more grip than a leather sole
Metallic silver and pink color options

Cons

Some colorways are faux leather, not genuine leather
Pointed toe can pinch wide feet
Kitten heel height is not for anyone wanting a taller heel
Limited new stock: one store listed

Sam Edelman Women's Kaya 2 Pump prices at every store

MercariNew
Availability unknown
$42.66Observed at 1:43 PM
Visit Mercari

Also available at

6pm.comCheck price at 6pm.com
Soles UnlimitedCheck price at Soles Unlimited

Sam Edelman Women's Kaya 2 Pump price history

Lowest price we've seen: $39.99 on Nov 7 at Soles Unlimited. Tracked across 3 stores since Nov 7.

What reviewers say

4.7 / 517 ratings

Buyers rate the Kaya 2 highly, at 4.7 out of 5 from 17 ratings. They tend to like the look and the walkable heel, with fit the main point of debate.

What people mention

ComfortPraisedOwners find the cushioned footbed and low heel comfortable for extended wear.
LookPraisedBuyers like the pointed toe and bit detail as a dressy, versatile finish.
FitMixedSome say the pointed toe runs narrow and can pinch.
MaterialMixedThe leather lining is liked, but some colorways are faux leather rather than genuine leather.

Specifications

Width: Width Medium
Department: Women's
Material: Faux Leather, Genuine Leather, Rubber
Heel Style: Kitten
Color: Silver, Soft Silver Metallic, Lolita Pink
Season: Spring, Summer, Winter, Fall
Embellishment Style: Bit

Questions and answers

Is the Kaya 2 comfortable for all-day wear?: The kitten heel and cushioned footbed make it easier to wear for long stretches than a high heel. The pointed toe can still pinch if your feet are wide.
Does it run true to size?: It is generally listed as medium width, but the pointed toe runs narrow for some buyers. Try your usual size first and size up if you have wide feet.
Is it leather or faux leather?: It depends on the colorway: some are genuine leather and some are faux leather, and all have a leather lining and rubber outsole. Check the material listed for the color you pick.
What heel height is the kitten heel?: It is a low kitten heel, roughly 2 inches or less, meant for a subtle lift rather than height.
Is $42.66 a good price?: That is the only new price listed, $42.66 at Mercari as of November 7, 2026, so there is no recent range to judge it against. It is a low price for a Sam Edelman pump.
Where is the Sam Edelman Women's Kaya 2 Pump cheapest?: At Mercari, for $42.66, as of our latest check.
What do buyers say about the Sam Edelman Women's Kaya 2 Pump?: Rated 4.7 out of 5 from 17 ratings.
Where can I buy the Sam Edelman Women's Kaya 2 Pump?: 3 stores we checked sell it, including Mercari, 6pm.com, Soles Unlimited.