Do the Broadwayy Mary Janes run true to size?

Owners generally report the fit is true to size, and the knit upper stretches, so most shoppers stay with their usual size.

Are they comfortable for standing all day?

Reviewers call them comfortable for long days, but the sole is thin, so shoppers who need arch support may want an insole.

Can I wear them to the office?

Yes. The square-toe Mary Jane shape reads smart-casual, though the knit upper is more relaxed than leather.

How do they compare with leather Mary Janes?

They are softer and lighter than leather Mary Janes, but they show wear sooner and look less polished.

What is the upper and sole made of?

The upper is fabric and the sole is man-made.

Are they good for travel?

Yes. They are light, slip on easily and pack flat.

What do buyers say about the Style & Co Broadwayy Knit Square Toe Mary Janes?

Rated 4.5 out of 5 from 272 ratings.

Where can I buy the Style & Co Broadwayy Knit Square Toe Mary Janes?

5 stores we checked sell it, including Macy's, ModeSens, eBay, Poshmark, Lyst.

Style & Co Broadwayy Knit Square Toe Mary Janes

Best price now

$27.94at Macy'sChecked Nov 2

Compared across 5 stores. Prices are checked against each store and labelled with when.

Visit Macy's

Style & Co Broadwayy Knit Square Toe Mary Janes

Best price now

$27.94at Macy'sChecked Nov 2

Compared across 5 stores. Prices are checked against each store and labelled with when.

Visit Macy's

Ask our agent about this product

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Price facts

Last seen at $27.94 at Macy's on Nov 2.
Checked at 5 stores.

Our take on the Style & Co Broadwayy Knit Square Toe Mary Janes

The Style & Co Broadwayy is a knit Mary Jane with a square toe and a flat, man-made sole. The stretch fabric upper gives where a leather strap shoe would not, and the square toe leaves room across the front of the foot. It suits shoppers who want a soft, packable flat for workdays and casual outfits. Against leather Mary Janes it trades structure and polish for comfort and a lower-maintenance upper.

Best forEveryday office wearWide or sensitive feetTravel and commutingCasual outfits with skirts or jeans

Pros

Knit upper flexes with the foot
Square toe gives room across the toes
Mary Jane strap holds the foot in place
Flat man-made sole is light and easy to walk in
Slips on and packs flat

Cons

Knit fabric shows wear and dirt faster than leather
Little arch or cushioning underfoot
Square toe can look boxy on narrow feet
Not dressy enough for formal occasions

Style & Co Broadwayy Knit Square Toe Mary Janes prices at every store

Macy'sNew
Availability unknown
$27.94Checked Nov 2
Visit Macy's
LystNew
Availability unknown
$27.94Checked Nov 2
Visit Lyst
ModeSensNew
Availability unknown
$28.00Checked Nov 2
Visit ModeSens
eBayNew
Availability unknown
$33.00Checked Nov 2
Visit eBay
PoshmarkNew
Availability unknown
$35.00Checked Nov 2
Visit Poshmark

Store links may earn us a commission.

Style & Co Broadwayy Knit Square Toe Mary Janes price history

Lowest price we've seen: $27.94 on Nov 2 at Macy's. Tracked across 5 stores since Nov 2.

What reviewers say

4.5 / 5272 ratings

Owners rate the Broadwayy highly and mostly praise its comfort, with the knit upper and square toe coming up as the reasons it works for long days on their feet.

What people mention

ComfortPraisedOwners say the shoe is comfortable from the first wear and holds up through a full day.
Knit upperPraisedReviewers like how the stretch fabric gives and does not pinch across the foot.
Square toeMixedSome find the roomy square toe a good fit for wider feet, while others say it looks boxy.
DurabilityCriticisedA few owners report the fabric looking worn after regular wear.
Underfoot supportCriticisedSome say the sole is thin and offers little cushioning under the ball of the foot.

From Lyst

Sizes: US 8 / 8M
Materials: Upper: fabric; sole: man-made
Sizing: The page directs shoppers to the retailer for up-to-date size availability and fit information.
Shipping: From Macy's; 3-6 business days; shipping excluded (free on orders over a stated amount).

About the Style & Co Broadwayy Knit Square Toe Mary Janes

These Mary Janes from Style & Co have a knit fabric upper and a square toe. The sole is man-made.

Brand: Style & Co
Upper: Fabric
Sole: Man-made
Toe shape: Square toe
Style: Mary Janes

Questions and answers

Do the Broadwayy Mary Janes run true to size?: Owners generally report the fit is true to size, and the knit upper stretches, so most shoppers stay with their usual size.
Are they comfortable for standing all day?: Reviewers call them comfortable for long days, but the sole is thin, so shoppers who need arch support may want an insole.
Can I wear them to the office?: Yes. The square-toe Mary Jane shape reads smart-casual, though the knit upper is more relaxed than leather.
How do they compare with leather Mary Janes?: They are softer and lighter than leather Mary Janes, but they show wear sooner and look less polished.
What is the upper and sole made of?: The upper is fabric and the sole is man-made.
Are they good for travel?: Yes. They are light, slip on easily and pack flat.
Where is the Style & Co Broadwayy Knit Square Toe Mary Janes cheapest?: At Macy's, for $27.94, as of our latest check.
What do buyers say about the Style & Co Broadwayy Knit Square Toe Mary Janes?: Rated 4.5 out of 5 from 272 ratings.
Where can I buy the Style & Co Broadwayy Knit Square Toe Mary Janes?: 5 stores we checked sell it, including Macy's, ModeSens, eBay, Poshmark, Lyst.