Is the Tarte Vanilla Icing Juicy Lip a plumper or just a gloss?

It is both: a stick gloss with a high-shine finish and a marketed plumping effect. Expect shine first and a mild plumping sensation second.

Plumping lip products often cause a tingling sensation, and some reviewers mention it here. If your lips are sensitive, test a small amount first.

Yes, Tarte lists this product as cruelty-free.

How much does it cost?

The best new price is $10.00 at tarte cosmetics as of November 8, 2026. Two stores list it new, so compare both before buying.

Is it worth it at $10?

At $10.00 it is a low-cost way to try a plumping gloss stick. Ratings are middling at 3.5 out of 5, so buy it for the shine and scent rather than dramatic plumping.

Where is the Tarte Vanilla Icing Juicy Lip cheapest?

At tarte cosmetics, for $10.00, as of our latest check.

What do buyers say about the Tarte Vanilla Icing Juicy Lip?

Rated 3.5 out of 5 from 13 ratings.

Where can I buy the Tarte Vanilla Icing Juicy Lip?

3 stores we checked sell it, including Ulta Beauty, tarte cosmetics, Whatnot.

Tarte Vanilla Icing Juicy Lip

Best price now

$10.00at tarte cosmeticsObserved at 12:08 AM

Compared across 2 stores. Prices are checked against each store and labelled with when.

Visit tarte cosmetics

Tarte Vanilla Icing Juicy Lip

Best price now

$10.00at tarte cosmeticsObserved at 12:08 AM

Compared across 2 stores. Prices are checked against each store and labelled with when.

Visit tarte cosmetics

Ask our agent about this product

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Our take on the Tarte Vanilla Icing Juicy Lip

Tarte Vanilla Icing Juicy Lip is a stick lip plumper in the Maracuja Juicy Lip Vinyl line, with a high-shine finish and a vanilla scent. It is cruelty-free and marketed for a plumped, glossy look. At $10.00 at tarte cosmetics as of November 8, 2026, it sits at the low end of what the two stores listing it new charge.

Best forShoppers who want shine and a light plumping effect in one stickVanilla-scent loversCruelty-free makeup buyersAnyone adding a gloss step to a simple routine

Pros

Stick form is easy to apply without a wand or gloss tube
High-shine vinyl finish
Marketed plumping effect
Cruelty-free
Low entry price at $10.00

Cons

Limited reception: 3.5 out of 5 from 13 ratings
Plumping tingle may not suit sensitive lips
Stick format gives less precise control than a doe-foot applicator
Shade range for this vanilla variant is narrow

Tarte Vanilla Icing Juicy Lip prices at every store

tarte cosmeticsNew
In stock
$10.00Observed at 12:08 AM
Visit tarte cosmetics
Ulta BeautyNew
In stock
$27.00+ $6.95 shippingObserved at 12:08 AM
Visit Ulta Beauty

Also available at

WhatnotCheck price at Whatnot

Store links may earn us a commission. Some prices via Klarna.

Tarte Vanilla Icing Juicy Lip price history

Lowest price we've seen: $10.00 on Nov 8 at tarte cosmetics. Tracked across 3 stores since Nov 8.

What reviewers say

3.5 / 513 ratings

Reception is modest, averaging 3.5 out of 5 from 13 ratings. Buyers tend to like the glossy finish and vanilla scent; complaints center on the plumping feel and staying power.

What people mention

FinishPraisedBuyers describe a glossy, vinyl-like shine after application.
ScentPraisedThe vanilla scent is called pleasant by several reviewers.
PlumpingMixedSome feel a tingle and slight plump; others notice little change.
Wear timeCriticisedReviewers say the shine fades and needs reapplying through the day.
Color payoffCriticisedThe tint reads sheer rather than as a full color.

Specifications

Form: Stick
Finish: Shine
Plumping: Yes
Color: Maracuja Juicy Lip Vinyl
Sustainability: Cruelty-free

Questions and answers

Is the Tarte Vanilla Icing Juicy Lip a plumper or just a gloss?: It is both: a stick gloss with a high-shine finish and a marketed plumping effect. Expect shine first and a mild plumping sensation second.
Does it tingle?: Plumping lip products often cause a tingling sensation, and some reviewers mention it here. If your lips are sensitive, test a small amount first.
Is it cruelty-free?: Yes, Tarte lists this product as cruelty-free.
How much does it cost?: The best new price is $10.00 at tarte cosmetics as of November 8, 2026. Two stores list it new, so compare both before buying.
Is it worth it at $10?: At $10.00 it is a low-cost way to try a plumping gloss stick. Ratings are middling at 3.5 out of 5, so buy it for the shine and scent rather than dramatic plumping.
Where is the Tarte Vanilla Icing Juicy Lip cheapest?: At tarte cosmetics, for $10.00, as of our latest check.
What do buyers say about the Tarte Vanilla Icing Juicy Lip?: Rated 3.5 out of 5 from 13 ratings.
Where can I buy the Tarte Vanilla Icing Juicy Lip?: 3 stores we checked sell it, including Ulta Beauty, tarte cosmetics, Whatnot.

Stores we've priced the Tarte Vanilla Icing Juicy Lip at

More from Tarte

All Tarte deals and products →