StoreDeal.ai store
Shop
  • Deals
  • Deal checker
  • Black Friday
  • Buying guides
  • Brands
  • Stores
Travel
  • Flight deals
  • Hotel deals
Company
  • Research
  • Press
  • Use in AI assistants
  • Contact
  • deal.ai apps
Black Friday 2026
  • Walmart
  • Best Buy
  • Target
  • TVs
  • Laptops
  • Headphones
  • Apple
  • Gaming
  • Vacuums
  • Kitchen
  • Toys
  • Smartwatches
  • Tablets
  • Furniture
  • Mattresses
© Deal.ai Inc.·2222 Ponce de Leon Blvd, Miami, FL 33134·support@deal.ai
TermsPrivacy
Deal.ai › Buying guides

Best gourmet cookies to buy online

Researched by Deal.ai's shopping agent across stores on November 16, 2026. Prices below are today's.

Top pick: The #1 NY Cookie — a thick, bakery-style cookie with the strongest track record of anything here (4.7 from over 7,000 ratings). If you want the classic "gourmet cookie shipped to my door" experience, start here.

Who the others suit:

  • Suga Mama Sweets Gourmet Cookies — small-batch, grass-fed butter, sold by the half-dozen or dozen; best for a thoughtful gift box.
  • Cheryl's Buttercream Assortment — the polished, corporate-gift choice when you need a big, presentable assortment.
  • Bahlsen Deloba cherry biscuits — for someone who prefers crisp, flaky European biscuits over soft-baked.
  • Knott's Berry Farm strawberry bites — crowd-pleasing, individually portioned, easy to share.
  • King Krumb limited editions — fun, trendy flavors (Dubai chocolate, banana split) at a low entry point; ratings are middling.
  • Bettergoods Belgian selection — a broad 12-variety butter-cookie tin for a table or office.

Skip the Nabisco variety pack and the peanut butter blossom kit if you're after gourmet — one's supermarket snack packs, the other's a bake-it-yourself mix.

The picks

T
The #1 NY Cookie
#1

The #1 NY Cookie

  • Pack size: boxes of 30 pieces
  • Piece weight: 95g
$10.00at Star CookiesChecked Nov 16Prices and history →
  • G
    Gourmet Cookies (6 Pack)
    #2

    Gourmet Cookies (6 Pack)

    • Pack Count: 6-Pack ( 1/2 dozen )
    • Cookie Weight: 2.05 - 2.25 ounces
    • Flour Type: unbleached flour
    • Butter Type: grass-fed butter
    $49.97at Suga Mama SweetsChecked Nov 16Prices and history →
  • Cheryl's Cookies
    Cheryl's Cookies Buttercream Cookies Assortment
    #3

    Cheryl's Cookies Buttercream Cookies Assortment

    • theme: Assorted
    • size: One Size
    $39.99at WalmartChecked Nov 16Compare 2 stores →
  • Bahlsen
    Bahlsen Deloba Puff Pastry Biscuits Cherry-Filled Gourmet Cookies - 3.5 Ounce Box (12 Pack)
    #4

    Bahlsen Deloba Puff Pastry Biscuits Cherry-Filled Gourmet Cookies - 3.5 Ounce Box (12 Pack)

    • Brand: Bahlsen
    • Flavor: Cherry
    • Cookie type: Biscuit Cookies
    • Texture: Flaky
    • Count: 12
    • Container type: Box
    $8.00at AmazonChecked Nov 16Compare 2 stores →
  • Knott's Berry Farm
    Knott's Berry Farm Premium Bite Cookies, Strawberry
    #5

    Knott's Berry Farm Premium Bite Cookies, Strawberry

    • Pack size: 36 ct
    • Flavor: Strawberry
    • Kosher: Kosher
    • Servings per container: 36
    • Serving size: 57.00
    • Calories: 240
    $9.99at eBayChecked Nov 9Compare 2 stores →
  • King Krumb
    King Krumb Limited Edition Dubai Chocolate & Toffee Almond Crunch Soft Baked Bakery Cookies
    #6

    King Krumb Limited Edition Dubai Chocolate & Toffee Almond Crunch Soft Baked Bakery Cookies

    • size: 11oz
    • Package weight: 11 oz
    • Pack count: 2 x 11 oz
    • Cookies per package: two large cookies each
    $5.97at WalmartChecked Nov 16Prices and history →
  • Bettergoods
    Bettergoods Luxury Selection Belgian Cookies 35.2 oz 12 Varieties
    #7

    Bettergoods Luxury Selection Belgian Cookies 35.2 oz 12 Varieties

    • Region of Origin: Europe
    • Net content: 17.6 oz
    • Cookie varieties: 12
    • Cookie type: Butter Cookies
    • Texture: crunchy
    • Count: 1
    $11.32at WalmartChecked Nov 16Prices and history →
  • King Krumb
    King Krumb Limited Edition Chocolate Lover’s Cookie Box
    #8

    King Krumb Limited Edition Chocolate Lover’s Cookie Box

    • size: 22oz
    $14.97at WalmartChecked Nov 16Prices and history →
  • King Krumb
    King Krumb Limited Edition Banana Split & Rainbow Blast Soft Baked Bakery Cookies
    #9

    King Krumb Limited Edition Banana Split & Rainbow Blast Soft Baked Bakery Cookies

    • size: 11oz
    • Count per pack: 2 ct
    • Net weight: 11 oz
    • Package count: 2 Count
    • Cookie style: Soft Baked
    • Edition: Limited Edition
    $4.97at WalmartChecked Nov 16Prices and history →
  • G
    Gourmet Cookies
    #10

    Gourmet Cookies

    • Serving size: 1 cookie (85g)
    • Servings per container: about 20
    • Calories: 430
    • Total fat: 23g
    • Saturated fat: 17g
    • Total carbohydrate: 53g
    $7.00at Paul's BakeryChecked Nov 16Compare 2 stores →
  • Jacques Torres Chocolate
    Jacques Torres Chocolate Cookie Gift Box
    #11

    Jacques Torres Chocolate Cookie Gift Box

    • Cookie Type: Cookie Mix
    • Highlighted Flavors: White Chocolate Chip, Macadamia
    • Secondary Flavor: Macadamia
    • Main Ingredients: Eggs (to be added), Butter (to be added)
    • Contains: White Chocolate Chip, Macadamia
    • Typical Users: Beginner bakers
    $24.99at Foodie City NetworkChecked Nov 16Compare 5 stores →
  • S
    Signature Cookie Assortment
    #12

    Signature Cookie Assortment

    • Cookie count options: 4, 8, or 12 cookies
    • Cookie weight: approx. 6 oz
    • Packaging: cellophane bags with hand-tied blue ribbons
    • Room temperature storage: up to 4 days
    • Freezer storage: up to 3 months
    • Reheat temperature: 350°F oven
    $49.99at Foodie City NetworkChecked Nov 8Compare 2 stores →
  • Ask our shopping agent

    It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

    Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

    More buying guides

    • Best OLED TVs under $1,500
    • Best electric bikes for commuting
    • Best cordless power tool combo kits
    • Best iPads
    • Best gaming laptops
    • Best cordless drill driver kits
    • Best DeWalt cordless power tool combo kits
    • Best MacBook Air laptops