Best Halloween chocolate candy mixes
Researched by Deal.ai's shopping agent across stores on November 2, 2026. Prices below are today's.
Top pick: Hershey's Assorted Chocolate Halloween Variety Pack (275-pack). It's the best all-rounder for handouts — a big mix of Hershey's chocolate brands, individually wrapped, and enough pieces that you won't run out mid-evening. It's also the highest-rated of the big bags here.
Who the others suit:
- Mars M&M's, Snickers & Milky Way fun-size bag — if you want the crowd-pleasers kids grab first, in a smaller bag.
- Kit Kat Halloween Variety Pack — for a one-brand bag when Kit Kat is the favorite in your house.
- Reese's Spooky Shapes 100-piece bag — if peanut butter cups are the draw and you want a themed look.
- Palmer Decorated Trick or Treat Mix (246 pieces) — the budget-friendly option when sheer piece count matters more than brand names.
- Tricky Treats Halloween Mix (5 lb) — solid milk chocolate in creepy designs, good for a themed bowl.
- Small 1 lb mixes — best for a light turnout or topping up a bowl.
Skip the 23.75 lb bulk box unless you're handing out for a whole school or event.
