Best men's American Eagle underwear

Top pick: AEO 6" Ultra Soft Boxer Briefs — the softest everyday pair here, with a supportive contoured pouch and no fly, so nothing rubs under jeans or chinos. Best if you want comfort first.

• AEO 6" Flex Boxer Briefs (5-pack) — the value buy: lightweight, brushed-soft performance fabric, enough pairs to skip laundry day.
• AEO 6" Classic Boxer Briefs (3-pack) — cotton-rich with a functional fly and anti-roll waistband; the traditional choice.
• AEO 4.5" Classic Boxer Briefs — shorter leg for guys who find 6" rides up or wear slim shorts.
• AEO Money 6" Flex Boxer Brief — same performance fabric, single pair, if you want to try one first.

Trunks: the 4.5" pairs are the trunk-length cut; the 6" ones are true boxer briefs.