Best organic cottage cheese
Researched by Deal.ai's shopping agent across stores on November 8, 2026. Prices below are today's.
Top pick: Good Culture Organic Whole Milk Cottage Cheese (16 oz). It's the one most people mean when they say cottage cheese tastes good — thick, creamy curds, live cultures, and a short ingredient list, with no gums or fillers doing the work. Buy the plain whole-milk version and add your own salt, pepper or fruit.
Who the others suit:
- Good Culture Organic Low-Fat — same thick texture with less fat, if you're watching calories but don't want watery curds.
- Good Culture Lactose Free — for anyone who loves the texture but not the lactose; single-serve cups are handy for lunches.
- Nancy's Organic Whole Milk — tangier, cultured flavor with live probiotics; best if you like cottage cheese with real bite.
- Organic Valley (2% or 4%) — the reliable everyday choice, widely stocked and mild enough for kids or baking.
- 365 by Whole Foods Market Organic — a straightforward, no-frills organic tub; good value if you go through a lot of it.
- Probiotic 4% (16 oz) — for probiotic-focused eaters who want a smaller-brand option.
Look for "organic" plus live and active cultures on the label, and check the date — cottage cheese turns quickly once opened.
The picks
- #1
Good Culture Organic Whole Milk Cottage Cheese
- Electrolytes: Calcium 80 mg, Potassium 90 mg, Sodium 340 mg
- Variety: Cottage Cheese
- Texture: Soft
- Cheese Weight: 16 oz
- Milk Type: Cow
- Fat Content: Whole Milk, 4% Milkfat
Ask our shopping agent
It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.






