Best women's boots for fall and winter

Top pick: Sorel Women's Out N About III Classic Waterproof. It's the boot that does the most for fall and winter: a fully waterproof bootie construction with a vulcanized rubber shell, so slush, rain and puddles stay out, plus a grippy lugged sole and a look that works with jeans or a coat. It's the one I'd buy first.

Who the others suit:

• Sorel Out N About III WP — same waterproofing in a lighter mesh-and-suede build; better if you want a sportier everyday boot.
• Manitobah Waterproof Snowy Owl — the warmest here, with sheepskin shearling lining and a tall shaft; pick it for deep cold and long walks in snow.
• Hunter Maribel Insulated Snow Booties — insulated suede ankle boots for cold city days when you want something tidier than a snow boot.
• Hunter Thunor Insulated Roll Top — a roll-top snow boot for heavy snow and slush.
• Ryka Devotion Max Winter — light and cushioned, good if you're on your feet a lot.
• TOMS Marlow — water-repellent rather than waterproof; fine for dry cold days and a dressier look.

Skip the cheap fashion listings if you need real weather protection — several are water-repellent or unlined at best.