Which shed is better for snow?

The W2505 is the only one with a published roof load: 14 psf maximum. The JolyDale lists no roof rating, so you cannot compare snow capacity.

Is the JolyDale worth the savings?

Only if the gap is large. The JolyDale has a 3.1-star rating from 12 buyers and no published specs, while the W2505 is $719.90 at Home Depot with a full spec sheet.

Do both include a floor?

Both include a metal base frame kit, not a solid floor panel. You still need a level base such as gravel or concrete under either shed.

The W2505 lists 693 cu ft of storage. The JolyDale does not publish a capacity figure, though the footprints are the same size.

Can I lock either shed?

The W2505 has a lockable door. The JolyDale's listing does not state a lock, so plan on adding a hasp if you buy it.

How long does assembly take?

Neither listing gives a build time. Both are metal panel kits of this size, which typically take two people most of a day.

10' x 12' Heavy-Duty Metal Outdoor Storage Shed with Floor Frame Kit vs JolyDale 10 ft. W x 12 ft. D Outdoor Metal Storage Shed with Metal Base Frame Kit

Both are 10 ft x 12 ft metal sheds with a base frame kit, so the choice comes down to details and price. The W2505 lists at $719.90 at Home Depot as of October 30, 2026, and its listing gives a full spec sheet: 693 cu ft, 14 psf roof load, vents, windows and a lockable door. The JolyDale's listing is thin and its 3.1 out of 5 from 12 ratings is a caution flag. Buy the W2505 unless the JolyDale is clearly cheaper at a store you trust.

Ask our shopping agent