Waterproof Recliner Slipcover vs 100% Waterproof Recliner Slipcover Rhombus

Buy the Rhombus (B) for most recliners. Its quilted three-layer build, silicone backing and buckle-and-strap system hold it in place far more reliably than the Square's elastic edging alone, and owners say spills bead off it. The Square (A) is the simpler, lighter cover and costs less to try, but owners report it slides and needs constant readjusting, and some arrived without the strap. B rates higher (4.8 from 203 ratings vs 4.5 from 311) and is the better long-term pick for pets, kids and daily use.

• Choose the Square if you want a light, simple cover for a standard recliner and you don't mind readjusting it now and then.
• Choose the Rhombus if you have pets or kids, an oversized recliner, or you're tired of covers that slide off.