simplehuman 14 oz. Sensor Pump Dish vs Brighter Barns Glass Soap Dispenser Set

The simplehuman Sensor Pump Dish is the better pick for anyone who wants hands-free, hygienic dish soap and doesn't mind charging a device. Its clog-proof tubing pump, drip-free silicone valve and 150,000-cycle rating are backed by a 2-year warranty, and owners rate it 4.8 out of 5 across more than 1,200 reviews. The Brighter Barns set is the better pick for someone who wants a simple, powered-free countertop piece: a 16 oz clear glass bottle, a 304 stainless steel pump and a ceramic tray, with no battery to charge and no sensor to fail. Build quality favors the simplehuman on the pump mechanism; the Brighter Barns wins on simplicity and looks.

• Choose the simplehuman Sensor Pump Dish if you want touch-free dispensing, a sponge caddy and a rechargeable pump that lasts months per charge.
• Choose the Brighter Barns glass dispenser if you want a manual pump with no power, a clear bottle that shows soap level and a matching ceramic tray.