Brighter Barns Glass Soap Dispenser Set vs JASAI 18 Oz Embossed Glass Soap Dispenser

The Brighter Barns set is the better pick for a kitchen sink that needs a complete, tidy setup: a 16 oz clear glass bottle, a 304 stainless steel pump and a ceramic tray to hold a sponge and catch drips. The JASAI is a single 18 oz embossed bottle with a rust-proof 304 pump, so it holds more soap and takes up less counter space but adds no tray. Both use clear glass and stainless pumps, so the real choice is set versus capacity and finish. Owners of both report the pumps hold up to daily wet use; the JASAI's embossed glass draws more comments on looks, the Brighter Barns on the matching tray.

• Choose the Brighter Barns set if you want a matching tray for the sponge and a coordinated look on the kitchen counter.
• Choose the JASAI if you want a larger bottle with fewer refills and an embossed finish, and you don't need a tray.