New Balance 327 Women's vs Superga 2750 Cotu Classics

The New Balance 327 is the more distinctive shoe: a flared midsole, trail-style lugged outsole and oversized N give it real presence, and the suede-and-nylon upper holds up better than plain canvas. The Superga 2750 is the simpler, cleaner pick, a flat low-top canvas sneaker that suits people who want a classic tennis silhouette and can machine wash it. Reviewers of the Superga praise the construction and breathability but often flag thin cushioning and weak arch support; the 327 is the better all-day walker for most women.

• Choose the New Balance 327 if you want a retro runner with real traction, a lifted flared sole and a suede-and-nylon upper that stands out.
• Choose the Superga 2750 if you want a flat, minimal canvas sneaker in a classic tennis shape that you can machine wash.