Superga 2750 Cotu Classics vs Women's Irvine

The Superga 2750 Cotu Classics is the better pick for a classic lace-up canvas look with a huge color range and a flat, low-profile silhouette. The Women's Irvine wins on comfort and convenience: a hands-free step-in design, a machine-washable canvas build and a much stronger owner rating. Superga owners praise the look and breathability but report little cushioning, no arch support and some sole separation; Irvine owners rate it far higher, though it is women's sizing only and comes in just four colors.

• Choose the Superga 2750 Cotu Classics if you want a lace-up tennis-style canvas sneaker in a wide choice of colors and a flat sole.
• Choose the Women's Irvine if you want a cushioned slip-on you can step into without hands and wash in the machine.