Which kit is better for beginners?

The Miss Rose kit is easier to start with because its matte shadows and blushes are forgiving and it includes brushes and a mirror. The All in One kit gives more finishes to experiment with but has no rating history to lean on.

Which has more eyeshadow colors?

The All in One kit lists 45 eyeshadows against 39 for Miss Rose. Miss Rose spreads its 58 pieces across blushes, powders, lipsticks and tools, while the All in One kit adds concealers.

Does either kit include concealer?

Only the All in One kit lists concealer, in medium and light shades. The Miss Rose kit has compact powder but no concealer.

Which is better for travel?

The All in One kit comes in a reusable train case organizer, which protects the powders better in a bag. The Miss Rose kit is a boxed palette with a mirror and is lighter to pack.

Are the kits waterproof?

Both list waterproof formulas. Powder products still need a setting spray for long wear, especially in humidity.

Is the All in One kit worth choosing over the rated Miss Rose kit?

Choose it if shimmer shades, concealer and the train case matter more to you than a proven 4.3 rating. Otherwise the Miss Rose kit is the safer pick.

58 Colors Professional Makeup Kit for Women Full Kit vs All in One Makeup Kit

Both are 58-piece all-in-one kits at similar prices, so the choice comes down to what you want in the box. The Miss Rose kit leans on 39 matte eyeshadows plus 6 blushes, 4 powders, 3 lipsticks and tools, and it has a 4.3 rating from 1,462 shoppers. The All in One kit adds 45 matte and shimmer shadows, medium and light concealers, a reusable train case and paraben-free, cruelty-free claims. Buy Miss Rose for a matte-heavy face and eye kit; buy the All in One kit for shimmer variety, concealer and sturdier packaging.

Ask our shopping agent