Neche 83" Upholstered Sofa vs Home Design Emerson Rolled Arm Sofa

The Neche is the bigger, softer, deeper couch: 83 inches wide, 22-inch seat depth, teddy fleece, an 850 lb capacity and two throw pillows. The Home Design Emerson is the more traditional, tidier piece, with rolled arms, nailhead trim and a skirted base that hides its legs. Owners of the Neche call it soft and easy to assemble but split on frame sturdiness, and its 3.9 rating reflects complaints about unclear labeling and thin back support. Buy the Neche for lounging space in a large room; buy the Emerson if you want a classic look that fits a smaller living room.

• Choose the Neche if you want a wide, deep, plush seat for three people to sprawl on and you have the floor space for an 83-inch couch.
• Choose the Home Design Emerson if you want a tailored, traditional silhouette with rolled arms and nailhead trim in a warm gray that suits a smaller room.