adidas Adistar XLG 2.0 vs ASICS GEL-NYC 2.0

Both are lifestyle sneakers styled after 2000s running shoes, not real running shoes. The Adistar XLG 2.0 is the safer pick for most people: it has Adiprene heel cushioning, an Adiwear rubber outsole, reflective details and a very wide size run up to US 16, and it holds a 4.7 average across far more ratings. The GEL-NYC 2.0 has the better cushioning stack on paper, with FF BLAST PLUS foam plus rearfoot and forefoot GEL and a TRUSSTIC shank, but owners often call it heavy with a tight toe box and a hard sole over long wear. Buy the ASICS if you want soft, plush landings and a snug heel; buy the adidas if you want a roomier, more durable everyday shoe in hard-to-find sizes.

• Choose the adidas Adistar XLG 2.0 if you want a roomier everyday sneaker with a durable Adiwear outsole, reflective details and sizes up to US 16.
• Choose the ASICS GEL-NYC 2.0 if you want the plusher cushioning of FF BLAST PLUS foam with GEL in the heel and forefoot, and you prefer a snug heel.