Saucony Grid Jazz 9 vs ASICS GEL-NYC 2.0

The ASICS GEL-NYC 2.0 is the better pick for most shoppers: it has a modern FF BLAST PLUS and GEL cushioning setup, AHAR rubber, and a 4.7 rating from 582 owners versus 4.2 from 62 for the Saucony. The Saucony Grid Jazz 9 is a lighter, flatter retro runner with suede overlays and a stability-leaning sole, and it suits people who want a simple casual sneaker. Owners of the ASICS praise the looks and short-walk comfort but report a tight toe box, noticeable weight and firm soles over long wear, so try it on if you have wide feet.

• Choose the Saucony Grid Jazz 9 if you want a lighter, flatter retro sneaker with suede overlays for everyday casual wear and prefer a roomier, less technical fit.
• Choose the ASICS GEL-NYC 2.0 if you want modern cushioning, a grippier AHAR outsole and a proven track record with hundreds of owners, and you mainly walk short distances.