Which is better for walking 18 holes?

The Payntr All Day SC is built for all-day comfort, with an Ortholite footbed that holds its cushioning and a breathable waterproof membrane. The Asics is padded and stable but heavier in feel for long walks.

Which has better traction?

The Payntr uses a TPU outsole with three-dimensional traction designed to last the shoe's life. The Asics uses a rubber and polyurethane outsole with a more conventional pattern.

Which is more stable during the swing?

The Asics targets swing stability with a reinforced back counter and inner support. The Payntr relies on its Ariaprene tongue lockdown and propulsion plate instead.

Is the Payntr worth stepping up to over the Asics?

If you want a plate and energy-return midsole in a spikeless shoe, yes. If you prefer a proven stability fit and a wider size range, the Asics is the safer pick.

The Payntr's TPU outsole is rated for the life of the shoe, and its Ortholite footbed resists compression. The Asics' rubber outsole is durable but less specifically rated.

Do both come in wide sizes?

The Asics is listed in standard D width across men's sizes 7 to 10. The Payntr's listed size range is narrower, so check width before buying.

PAYNTR Golf All Day SC vs Asics Gel-Kayano Ace 2 Golf Shoes

The Payntr All Day SC is the more technical spikeless shoe: a propulsion plate, a nitrogen-infused midsole and a waterproof membrane built into the lining. The Asics Gel-Kayano Ace 2 leans on its stability-running heritage, with a reinforced back counter and heel padding for a locked-in fit. Reviewers rate the Payntr higher on average, but from a much smaller pool of ratings than the Asics. Buy the Payntr for energy return and a plate underfoot; buy the Asics for proven stability and a wider range of sizes.

Choose the Payntr All Day SC if you want a spikeless shoe with a propulsion plate and maximum energy return underfoot.
Choose the Asics Gel-Kayano Ace 2 if you want a stable, well-padded fit backed by a long-running stability shoe design.

Prices

PAYNTR Golf All Day SC: $159.99 at Worldwide Golf Shops (last seen Nov 8)
Asics Gel-Kayano Ace 2 Golf Shoes: $64.97 at Rock Bottom Golf (last seen Nov 4)
Difference: the Asics Gel-Kayano Ace 2 Golf Shoes is $95.02 cheaper than the PAYNTR Golf All Day SC at the latest prices (Nov 4 and Nov 8)

	PAYNTR Golf All Day SC	Asics Gel-Kayano Ace 2 Golf Shoes
Underfoot	PMXNITROGEN+ midsole for energy return plus a PMXSpeedPLT propulsion plate	GEL-Kayano running-derived cushioning, no propulsion plate
Upper	Clarino microfiber with an Ariaprene tongue for lockdown	Synthetic upper with reinforced back counter and padded tongue
Waterproofing	Waterproof+ breathable membrane fused to the lining with a sealed bottom gasket	Listed as waterproof, no membrane detail given
Stability	Plate and tongue lockdown aid ground reaction	Back counter and inner reinforcement target swing stability
Outsole	TPU outsole with three-dimensional traction	Rubber and polyurethane outsole
Sizing	Fewer listed sizes	Men's 7 to 10 in standard D width
Ratings	4.8 from 109 ratings	4.5 from 453 ratings
Awards	Named 2025 Spikeless Shoe of the Year by MyGolfSpy	No comparable award

Spec	PAYNTR Golf All Day SC	Asics Gel-Kayano Ace 2 Golf Shoes
Numeric Size	—	10
Fit Width	—	Standard, D standard
Gender Size	—	Men's 10, Men's 7, Men's 8, Men's 9, Men's 9.5
Men'S Size	—	Size 10, Size 7, Size 8, Size 9, Size 9.5
Age Group Size	—	Adult size
Department	—	Men's
Suitable For Size	—	Men's Size
Age Group	—	Adult
Typical Users	—	Golfers
Occasion	—	Athletic
Running Shoes	—	No
Weightlifting Shoes	—	No

Spec	PAYNTR Golf All Day SC	Asics Gel-Kayano Ace 2 Golf Shoes
Gore-Tex	—	No
Running Style	—	Neutral
Color	—	Gray
Outsole	—	Rubber, Polyurethane
Gender	—	Male
Size (US)	—	11, 12, 6.5, 9.5, 10.5, 8.5, 8, 9, 11.5, 7.5, 6…
Series	—	Asics Gel-Kayano
Fastening	—	Laced
Lining	—	Polyurethane, Mesh
Upper Material	—	Mesh, TPU

PAYNTR Golf All Day SC vs Asics Gel-Kayano Ace 2 Golf Shoes

Prices

PAYNTR Golf All Day SC vs Asics Gel-Kayano Ace 2 Golf Shoes

Prices

Asics Gel-Kayano Ace 2 Golf Shoes

What separates them

Price history

Prices at every store