PAYNTR Golf All Day SC vs FootJoy Pro/SL Golf Shoe

Both are spikeless golf shoes built for walking, and both earn strong marks from owners. The All Day SC leans toward a waterproof, energy-return build with a propulsion plate and a waterproof membrane sealed to a gasket; it won a 2025 spikeless shoe of the year award. The Pro/SL leans toward fit and stability, with a roomier toe box, four width options, a nylon spring plate and a heel crash pad. Pick the All Day SC for wet conditions and a springier ride; pick the Pro/SL for a wider fit and a more athletic profile.

• Choose the All Day SC if you play in wet or dewy conditions and want a waterproof membrane plus a propulsion plate underfoot.
• Choose the Pro/SL if you need a wider toe box and multiple width options, and want a proven walking shoe with a heel crash pad.