StoreDeal.ai store
Shop
  • Deals
  • Deal checker
  • Black Friday
  • Buying guides
  • Brands
  • Stores
Travel
  • Flight deals
  • Hotel deals
Company
  • Research
  • Press
  • Use in AI assistants
  • Contact
  • deal.ai apps
Black Friday 2026
  • Walmart
  • Best Buy
  • Target
  • TVs
  • Laptops
  • Headphones
  • Apple
  • Gaming
  • Vacuums
  • Kitchen
  • Toys
  • Smartwatches
  • Tablets
  • Furniture
  • Mattresses
© Deal.ai Inc.·2222 Ponce de Leon Blvd, Miami, FL 33134·support@deal.ai
TermsPrivacy
Deal.ai › Compare

All in One Makeup Kit with Storage Bag vs SHANY Color Vibe All in One Makeup Set

Choose the SHANY Color Vibe kit if you want range and proven satisfaction: 4.6 stars from 426 ratings, 80 eyeshadow shades, and a 7-layer case that folds into a compact box. Choose the All in One Makeup Kit if you want a full starter set with 20 brushes, a storage bag, and liquid and cream products like foundation, concealer and BB cream. The SHANY kit carries the stronger buyer track record and the wider shade range; the All in One kit wins on tools and liquid base products. Compare live prices before buying.

  • Choose the All in One Makeup Kit if you want brushes and liquid base products included, not just palettes.
  • Choose the SHANY Color Vibe kit if you want the widest shade range and the stronger track record with buyers.

Prices

  • All in One Makeup Kit with Storage Bag: $17.99 at Amazon (last seen Nov 21)
  • SHANY Color Vibe All in One Makeup Set: $15.99 at Target (last seen Nov 9)
  • Difference: the SHANY Color Vibe All in One Makeup Set is $2.00 cheaper than the All in One Makeup Kit with Storage Bag at the latest prices (Nov 9 and Nov 21)
A
All in One Makeup Kit with Storage Bag

All in One Makeup Kit with Storage Bag

3.8(55 ratings)
$17.99at AmazonChecked 22 h ago
See all prices and details
Visit Amazon

Store links may earn us a commission. As an Amazon Associate, Deal.ai earns from qualifying purchases.

Pros
  • 20 brushes included, enough for eyes, face and blending
  • Liquid foundation, concealer and BB cream cover base makeup
  • Waterproof, sweat-proof formulas
  • Bag doubles as a purse and gift packaging
  • Buyers call it well-made and built to last
Cons
  • 3.8 out of 5 from only 55 ratings
  • Just 28 eyeshadow shades across two palettes
  • Powder, cream, liquid and pencil forms in one bag can be messy to pack
M
Makeup Kit For Eyes, Lips, And Face, With Eyeshadows, Lipsticks, Highlighter, Bronzer, and More, Accessories Included, Travel In Colour

SHANY Color Vibe All in One Makeup Set

Makeup Kit For Eyes, Lips, And Face, With Eyeshadows, Lipsticks, Highlighter, Bronzer, and More, Accessories Included, Travel In Colour

4.6(426 ratings)
$15.99at TargetChecked Nov 9
See all prices and details
Visit Target
Pros
  • 4.6 out of 5 from 426 ratings
  • 80 eyeshadow shades plus lip, blush, brow and powder layers
  • Folds into a compact box for travel
  • Cruelty-free and PETA member, with SPF 30 BB cream
  • Designed in the U.S.A. by makeup professionals
Cons
  • No brushes, only applicators
  • No liquid foundation
  • Water-resistant rather than waterproof
  • Large 7-layer case takes space when open

What separates them

All in One Makeup Kit with Storage BagSHANY Color Vibe All in One Makeup Set
Shade count2 x 14-color eyeshadow palettes plus 6 lip glosses80 eyeshadow, 20 lip, 10 cream shadow, 5 brow, 5 concealer/corrector, 5 blush, 5 powder
Brushes and tools20 vegan brushes includedApplicators included
Base makeupLiquid foundation, liquid concealer, BB creamConcealer and color correctors, no liquid foundation
PackagingStorage bag that doubles as a purse7-layer case that folds into a compact box
WaterproofingWaterproof and sweat-proofWater-resistant
Ratings3.8 out of 5 from 55 ratings4.6 out of 5 from 426 ratings
SPFSPF in the setSPF 30 in the BB cream
TextureCreamy sticks, liquids, powders and pencilsPressed powder palette
Skin suitabilityHypoallergenic, all skin types, sulfate- and paraben-freeHypoallergenic, sensitive skin, dark skin tones, unscented, non-toxic
Gift appealReusable storage bag presented as a gift for birthdays, holidays and weddingsGift-style packaging with premium protection inside and outside the box

Price history

$24.99$12.99
Oct 31Nov 21
  • All in One Makeup Kit with Storage Bag: lowest $15.99 on Nov 10 at Amazon; $17.99 on Nov 21.
  • SHANY Color Vibe All in One Makeup Set: lowest $12.99 on Nov 9 at eBay.

Prices at every store

All in One Makeup Kit with Storage Bag

  • WalmartNew

    In stock

    $33.24+ $6.99 shippingChecked 22 h ago
    Visit Walmart
  • AmazonNew

    Availability unknown

    As an Amazon Associate, Deal.ai earns from qualifying purchases.

    $17.99Checked 22 h ago
    Visit Amazon
  • MercariNew

    Availability unknown

    $45.00Checked 22 h ago
    Visit Mercari
  • eBayNew

    Availability unknownSold by makeupandgiftshop2014

    $49.98Checked 22 h ago
    Visit eBay

Store links may earn us a commission.

All 8 stores and price history →

SHANY Color Vibe All in One Makeup Set

  • TargetNew

    In stock

    $15.99+ $5.99 shippingChecked Nov 9
    Visit Target
  • DoorDashNew

    In stockSold by Target US

    $19.99+ $5.99 shippingChecked Nov 9
    Visit DoorDash
  • ShiptNew

    In stock

    $15.99+ $17.00 shippingChecked Nov 9
    Visit Shipt

Also available at

  • eBayCheck price at eBay
  • Milani CosmeticsCheck price at Milani Cosmetics
  • SilkruteCheck price at Silkrute

Store links may earn us a commission.

All 3 stores and price history →

Specs compared

SpecAll in One Makeup Kit with Storage BagSHANY Color Vibe All in One Makeup Set
Color14 colors (Eyeshadow Palette)Bronze, Blues, Gold, Greens, Oranges
Color FamilyEveryday neutrals, Bold party huesWarm colors, Cool tones
Finish HighlightsMatteMatte
Primary FinishMatteMatte
Texture TypeCreamyPowder
Body Part UseLips, Eyes, FaceEyes, Lips
Application MethodContouring, Application, BlendingApplicators
Best For Skin TypeAll skin typesAll
HypoallergenicYesYes
Primary EffectShimmer, Contour, MatteShimmer
WaterproofYesWater-Resistant
With Color CorrectorYesYes
Show all 32 specsShow fewer specs
SpecAll in One Makeup Kit with Storage BagSHANY Color Vibe All in One Makeup Set
Free OfSulfate-free, Harsh chemicals-free, Paraben-freeCruelty-free, Non Toxic
With SPFYesYes (SPF 30 in BB Cream)
Form TypeStick, Liquid, Palette, Pencil, PowderPalette
Buildable CoverageYesYes
Actual ColorBLACKCOLOR VIBE
size3.00001.5000
With TintYes—
Is A PaletteYes—
Is A SetYes—
Container Type

What reviewers say

All in One Makeup Kit with Storage Bag

  • 3.8 / 555 ratings

Buyers are mostly gift givers and beginners, and they rate it as a complete, well-made starter set. The 3.8 average shows a meaningful minority found it short of expectations.

What people mention
  • Gift appealPraisedBuyers repeatedly describe it as a ready-made gift for birthdays, holidays and Mother's Day.
  • Beginner coveragePraisedOwners say it has all the basics and enough color variety for someone starting out.
  • Storage bagPraisedThe case is liked enough that buyers use it as a purse.
  • Build qualityMixedSome call it well-made and built to last, while others were unhappy with what they received.

SHANY Color Vibe All in One Makeup Set

  • 4.6 / 5426 ratings

Rated 4.6 out of 5 from 426 ratings, buyers mostly treat it as a gift or starter kit and value the amount of color it offers. Complaints center on uneven pigmentation and the bulky case rather than the concept.

What people mention
  • Shade rangePraisedBuyers like the wide mix of eyes, lips and face colors in one kit.
  • PigmentationMixedSome shades show well while others apply sheer or need building up.
  • Gift appealPraisedThe packaging and size make it a popular present for teens and beginners.
  • Case sizeCriticised

Questions and answers

Which kit is better for beginners?
The All in One kit is easier to start with because it includes 20 brushes and liquid foundation, concealer and BB cream. The SHANY kit gives more shades but expects you to supply your own brushes.
Which has more colors?
The SHANY Color Vibe kit, by a wide margin: 80 eyeshadow shades plus 20 lip colors and separate blush, brow and powder layers. The All in One kit has 28 eyeshadow shades and 6 lip glosses.
Which is better for travel?
The SHANY kit folds into a compact box, which packs neatly. The All in One bag doubles as a purse but holds loose liquids and pencils.
Is the All in One kit waterproof?
Yes, the formulas are listed as waterproof and sweat-proof. The SHANY kit is only water-resistant.
Is the SHANY kit worth the extra over the All in One kit?
It depends on the gap between the two at checkout. If the gap is small, the SHANY kit's 4.6 rating from 426 buyers and far larger shade range make it the safer pick.
Are either tested on animals?
Both are cruelty-free. The All in One kit's brushes are listed as vegan, and SHANY states it is a PETA member.
Is the SHANY kit worth stepping up to over the All in One kit?
If you already own brushes and want shade range, yes: 4.6 stars from 426 buyers and 80 eyeshadow shades against 3.8 stars from 55. If you need foundation, concealer and brushes in one box, the All in One kit covers more of a routine.
Which is better for sensitive or dark skin tones?
The SHANY kit is the clearer pick: it is listed as hypoallergenic, unscented, suitable for sensitive skin and made for dark skin tones. The All in One kit is hypoallergenic and free of sulfates and parabens but does not list dark-tone suitability.
Which kit is better for a teenager?
The All in One kit is the common pick for a teenager: buyers describe giving it to a granddaughter who said it has everything she needs, and the bag doubles as a purse. The SHANY kit suits a teen who wants many shades and already has brushes.
Does the SHANY kit work for sensitive skin?
Yes. It is listed as hypoallergenic, unscented, non-toxic and suitable for sensitive skin, and it is made for all skin types.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

More comparisons

  • AOLIKOKO All-in-One Makeup Kit for Women vs All in One Makeup Kit with Storage Bag
  • AOLIKOKO All-in-One Makeup Kit for Women vs Makeup Kit For Eyes, Lips, And Face, With Eyeshadows, Lipsticks, Highlighter, Bronzer, and More, Accessories Included, Travel In Colour
Bag
—
Packaging TypeBag—
Tinted Cream TypeBB cream—
Quantity Count20 (makeup brushes)—
Eye Color—Bronze, Blues, Gold, Greens, Oranges
Powder Type—Pressed powder
Coverage Level—Full
For Sensitive Skin—Yes
For Dark Skin Tones—Yes
Night / Day Use—Night, Day
Unscented—Yes
The seven-layer case is bulky and awkward to use away from a table.