Which kit is better for beginners?

The All in One kit is easier to start with because it includes a bag, two palettes and 20 brushes in one box. The AOLIKOKO kit has the stronger rating, so pick it if reviews matter more to you than extras.

Which has more eyeshadow colors?

The All in One kit has 28 shades across two 14-color palettes. The AOLIKOKO kit has 27 eye shadows in one palette.

Is the All in One kit worth the extra over the AOLIKOKO kit?

At $24.99 as of October 31, 2026, the All in One kit adds a bag, SPF, waterproof formulas and 10 more brushes. The AOLIKOKO kit wins on rating, 4.5 versus 3.8.

Which kit lasts longer?

Neither listing gives a shelf life. The All in One kit claims waterproof, long-lasting formulas, which may hold up better through a long day.

Are both kits hypoallergenic and paraben-free?

Yes. Both list hypoallergenic and paraben-free. The All in One kit also claims sulfate-free and harsh-chemical-free.

Which is the better gift?

The All in One kit comes in a storage bag that can double as a purse, which makes it the easier gift. The AOLIKOKO kit has the better rating if the recipient checks reviews.

AOLIKOKO All-in-One Makeup Kit for Women vs All in One Makeup Kit with Storage Bag

Buy the AOLIKOKO kit if you want a proven, higher-rated set with 27 eyeshadows and 10 brushes; its 4.5 rating from 426 ratings is far stronger than the 3.8 from 55 ratings on the All in One kit. The All in One kit adds a storage bag, two 14-color palettes, 20 brushes and SPF, and its lowest daily price was $24.99 as of October 31, 2026. Neither listing gave a current price from a named store, so compare live store prices before you commit.

Ask our shopping agent