Which is warmer, the AllSaints trench or the Hatoys pea coat?

The Hatoys is marketed as thermal insulated and is ankle length, so it should be warmer. The AllSaints is a 100% cotton shell with no stated fill, so treat it as a fall and spring coat or a layer over a sweater.

Is the AllSaints worth eight times the Hatoys price?

If you wear a trench often and want cotton, a known brand and a real returns policy, yes. If you need a costume or occasional coat, the $44.99 Hatoys covers that at low risk.

How long is the Hatoys coat?

About 138 cm at the back in size L, roughly 54 inches, which is ankle length on most men. Check the size chart before ordering, since it runs long.

Does the AllSaints trench come in sizes and colors?

The listing does not state color options or a size range. Check the Amazon product page for the current size run before you buy.

The AllSaints, on materials alone: a 100% cotton shell from an established label is easier to repair and clean than an undisclosed wool blend from a marketplace seller.

Can I wear either in real winter?

The Hatoys claims insulation and ankle coverage, so it suits cold weather better. The AllSaints cotton trench needs a heavy layer underneath for freezing temperatures.

AllSaints Men's Long Trench Coat vs Hatoys Wool Blend Pea Coat

Buy the AllSaints if you want a real cotton trench with a known brand and a fit you can trust; buy the Hatoys if budget is the whole decision and you accept a wool-blend look-alike at a fraction of the cost. The gap is large: $377.81 at Amazon for the AllSaints versus $44.99 at Walmart for the Hatoys, both as of November 5, 2026. At roughly eight times the price, the AllSaints is the better coat; the Hatoys is the cheaper gamble.

Today the Hatoys Wool Blend Pea Coat costs $332.82 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.