Which is better for rain?

The Resistance. It is waterproof oilskin cotton with a throat latch and snap cuffs. The AllSaints is plain cotton with no waterproof claim.

Is the AllSaints worth the extra money?

Only if you want the trench look for city wear. It costs $377.81 versus $80.99, and the extra buys style, not weather protection.

The Resistance is built for ranch work and heavy use, but oilskin needs re-waxing over time. The AllSaints cotton trench is lighter and will show wear sooner under hard use.

Can I wear the Resistance duster for everyday city use?

Yes, but it reads as western workwear. The AllSaints fits casual everyday outfits more easily.

Does the Resistance come in larger sizes?

Yes. The listed size is 4XL, and it is sold at 4 stores, so check each for available sizes.

Which is better for horseback riding?

The Resistance. It has a rear saddle gusset, an adjustable throat latch and a long cut for coverage in the saddle.

AllSaints Men's Long Trench Coat vs Resistance Oilskin Duster Coat

Buy the Resistance duster if you need real rain protection or ride horses; it costs $80.99 at Amazon as of November 5, 2026. Buy the AllSaints trench if you want a cotton city coat for fall and spring wear; it costs $377.81 at Amazon as of November 5, 2026. The Resistance is roughly $297 cheaper and is built for weather, while the AllSaints is a fashion piece with no waterproofing claim.

Today the Resistance Oilskin Duster Coat costs $296.82 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.