Alpine Sleigh Shovel vs Garant True-Temper 24" Poly Sleigh Shovel

Buy the Garant True-Temper if you clear wide driveways and want to push snow rather than lift it; its 36.8-inch UHMW blade moves far more per pass and the Versa Grip gives several hand positions. Buy the Alpine Sleigh Shovel if you want a narrower, simpler steel-handled scoop that is easier to steer in tight spots and around parked cars. Both are poly sleigh scoops with steel wear strips, so build is close; the Garant is the heavier-duty pusher, the Alpine the more compact all-rounder.

• Choose the Alpine Sleigh Shovel if you have a narrow drive, tight parking, or want a lighter, simpler scoop with a plain steel handle.
• Choose the Garant True-Temper if you clear wide open areas and want a big UHMW blade with a multi-position grip for pushing and unloading.