Garant 24in Poly Sleigh Snow Shovel vs Alpine Sleigh Shovel

Both are poly sleigh shovels with steel wear strips and steel handles, so they clear snow the same way: push and slide rather than lift. The Garant is the better-documented tool, with a 24 in blade, a 30.5 in intake height and 706 ratings averaging 4.7, and its ergonomic handle is the one owners most often praise for back comfort. The Alpine is close in size at 23.5 in wide with a slightly longer 62 in overall length, but it weighs about 10.8 lbs against the Garant's roughly 11.7 lbs, so the two are near even on heft. Buy the Garant for a proven, widely reviewed sleigh shovel; pick the Alpine if you want the longer handle and a baked enamel finish on the steel.

• Choose the Garant 24in Poly Sleigh Snow Shovel if you want the sleigh shovel with the largest body of owner feedback and a 24 in blade with a tall 30.5 in intake.
• Choose the Alpine Sleigh Shovel, 62-In. if you want a slightly longer 62 in overall handle and a gray baked enamel finish on the steel.