DealsBuying guidesBrandsStoresTermsPrivacydeal.ai apps

© Deal.ai Inc.

Deal.ai › Compare

Amana Bone-In Spiral Sliced Smoked Ham, 12-14 lb. vs Fully Cooked, Spiral Cut, Smoked, Bone-in Ham - Half

Buy the Amana ham if you want a big bone-in centerpiece for a crowd and value hickory smoke and a gluten-free label. Buy the Paulina Market half ham if you want a smaller honey-glazed applewood-smoked ham for a household or a smaller gathering. The Amana is a 12–14 lb ham; the Paulina half is about 7–9 lbs. No current prices were provided for either, so compare store prices on Deal.ai before you buy.

Ask our shopping agent

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

Amana
Amana Bone-In Spiral Sliced Smoked Ham, 12-14 lb.

Amana Bone-In Spiral Sliced Smoked Ham, 12-14 lb.

5· 14 ratings

Choose the Amana ham if you are feeding a large group and want a fully cooked, gluten-free, hickory-smoked spiral ham with a bone for soup afterward.

Pros
  • Large 12–14 lb size suits a big holiday table or a gift.
  • Fully cooked and heat-and-eat, so little work before serving.
Hickory smoke and a bone that works for ham and bean soup.
  • Gluten-free label.
  • Rated 5 out of 5 from 14 ratings.
    • Cons
    • Too big for a small household; expect lots of leftovers.
    • No honey glaze.
    • Fresh, so it needs to be cooked or frozen promptly.
    • No price was provided to compare.
    F
    Fully Cooked, Spiral Cut, Smoked, Bone-in Ham - Half

    Fully Cooked, Spiral Cut, Smoked, Bone-in Ham - Half

    Choose the Paulina half ham if you want a smaller honey-glazed, applewood-smoked spiral ham that fits a smaller oven and a smaller crowd.

    Pros
    • Honey glaze and applewood smoke give a sweeter, smokier flavor.
    • Smaller 7–9 lb half fits smaller ovens and crowds.
    • Not a water-added product.
    • Can be refrigerated up to 5 weeks or frozen for later.
    • Wisconsin State Fair Seal of Excellence.
    Cons
    • No gluten-free claim listed.
    • Reheating takes about 1.5–2 hours at 325°F.
    • Smaller size may not cover a large gathering.
    • No price was provided to compare.

    What separates them

    Amana Bone-In Spiral Sliced Smoked Ham, 12-14 lb.Fully Cooked, Spiral Cut, Smoked, Bone-in Ham - Half
    Size12–14 lbAbout 7–9 lb (half)
    Glaze and flavorHickory-smoked, no honey glaze listedHoney-glazed, applewood-smoked
    BoneBone-inBone-in
    CutSpiral-slicedSpiral-sliced, uniform slices
    PreparationHeat and eat, fully cookedFully cooked, reheat about 1.5–2 hr at 325°F
    Dietary labelGluten-freeNo gluten-free claim listed
    StorageFreshRefrigerate up to 5 weeks or freeze
    Water addedNot statedNot a water-added product

    Price history

    • Amana Bone-In Spiral Sliced Smoked Ham, 12-14 lb.: lowest $114.95 on Nov 2 at Amana Meat Shop.
    • Fully Cooked, Spiral Cut, Smoked, Bone-in Ham - Half: lowest $84.99 on Nov 2 at Nueske's.

    Prices at every store

    Amana Bone-In Spiral Sliced Smoked Ham, 12-14 lb.

    • Amana Meat Shop & SmokehouseCheck price at Amana Meat Shop & Smokehouse
    • Amana Meat ShopCheck price at Amana Meat Shop
    Prices and history →

    Fully Cooked, Spiral Cut, Smoked, Bone-in Ham - Half

    • Nueske'sCheck price at Nueske's
    • Prime Time ButcherCheck price at Prime Time Butcher
    • The Linz ShopCheck price at The Linz Shop
    Prices and history →

    Specs compared

    SpecAmana Bone-In Spiral Sliced Smoked Ham, 12-14 lb.Fully Cooked, Spiral Cut, Smoked, Bone-in Ham - Half
    CutSpiral-SlicedSpiral Sliced, Bone-In
    Weight range12-14 lb.—
    Serving size3/4 lb.—
    DietaryGluten-Free—
    Smoking woodhickory wood—
    Cooking statefully cooked—
    BoneBone-In—
    VarietyHam—
    Fresh / FrozenFresh—
    TypePork—
    Style—Ham
    Subtype—Honey Glazed Ham
    Show all 26 specsShow fewer specs
    SpecAmana Bone-In Spiral Sliced Smoked Ham, 12-14 lb.Fully Cooked, Spiral Cut, Smoked, Bone-in Ham - Half
    Storage Method—Refrigerated, Frozen
    Form—Slices
    Thickness—Uniform slices, Uniformly spiral sliced
    Highlighted Flavors—Honey
    Meat Type—Ham
    Free Of—Water-added product (not a water-added product)
    Added Ingredients—Honey Glaze
    Preparation Method—Spiral slicing technique
    Smoked Status—Smoky Applewood flavor

    What reviewers say

    Amana Bone-In Spiral Sliced Smoked Ham, 12-14 lb.

    Buyers rate it 5 out of 5 across 14 ratings and describe it as one of the best hams they have had. Several mention guests raving about it at Thanksgiving and using the bone and bits for ham and bean soup.

    Pros
    • Shipped on time and arrived well packed
    • Guests raved about the flavor
    • Worked well as a Thanksgiving centerpiece
    • The bone and trimmings made good ham and bean soup
    Cons
    • No recurring complaints in the available ratings

    Fully Cooked, Spiral Cut, Smoked, Bone-in Ham - Half

    Owners of spiral-cut smoked hams like this one generally praise the convenience, the sweet glaze and the smoky flavor, and note that the bone keeps slices moist. Common complaints are that the honey glaze is too sweet for some and that the spiral cuts can dry out if reheated past the suggested time.

    Pros
    • Easy to serve thanks to spiral cuts
    • Sweet honey glaze and smoky applewood flavor
    • Bone-in keeps meat moist
    • Fully cooked saves oven time
    Cons
    • Glaze can be too sweet
    • Edges dry out when reheated too long
    • Bone-in is heavier to handle
    • Large half takes up fridge space

    Questions and answers

    Which ham is better for a large holiday dinner?
    The Amana ham. At 12–14 lb it feeds a bigger crowd, and it is fully cooked and heat-and-eat. The Paulina half is about 7–9 lb, better for a smaller group.
    Which one has more flavor?
    The Paulina half is honey-glazed and applewood-smoked, so it is sweeter and smokier. The Amana is hickory-smoked with no honey glaze listed.
    Is either ham gluten-free?
    The Amana ham is labeled gluten-free. The Paulina listing makes no gluten-free claim, so check its label if that matters to you.
    How long does each take to prepare?
    Both are fully cooked. The Amana is heat-and-eat. The Paulina half needs about 1.5–2 hours at 325°F to reheat.
    Can I freeze the leftovers?
    Yes for both. The Paulina listing says it can be refrigerated up to 5 weeks or frozen. Freeze sliced Amana leftovers in portions and use the bone for soup.
    Is the Paulina half worth it over the bigger Amana ham?
    It depends on your crowd. For a small household, the smaller honey-glazed half means less waste. For a big gathering, the Amana size wins. Compare current store prices on Deal.ai.

    Buying guides that pick them

    • Best spiral cut hams
    Weight
    —
    7 lbs (Half)
    Count—1 (ham)
    Country—America (awarded one of America's Best)
    Region—Wisconsin State Fair (earned the coveted Seal o…
    Preservation Method—Refrigerate (if used within 5 weeks), Freeze (t…