Amana Bone-In Spiral Sliced Smoked Ham vs Marketside Bone-In Spiral-Cut Ham

Buy the Amana if you want a larger bone-in ham for a big holiday table or a gift, and you value hickory smoke over sweetness. Buy the Marketside if you want a brown sugar double glaze, a smaller ham, and a track record backed by tens of thousands of ratings. Both are fully cooked, spiral-cut and bone-in, so the real split is size, glaze and smoke style. Amana's 5-star rating comes from only 14 reviews, while Marketside's 4.4 comes from over 24,000, so the Marketside score is far more reliable.

• Choose the Amana if you are feeding a crowd of 16 or more, want a plain hickory-smoked ham without a sweet glaze, or need a gift-size centerpiece.
• Choose the Marketside if you want a smaller brown sugar glazed ham, prefer a sweeter crust, or want the confidence of a rating built on tens of thousands of buyers.