Antique Brass Taper Candle Holder vs Black Iron Flat Star Candle Holder

Buy the McGee & Co. brass candlestick set if you want a finished, well-reviewed trio that owners call well made and true to the photos. Buy the black iron star if you want one low, rustic accent piece and don't mind assembling it. The brass set is the safer pick on build and consistency; the star is the more casual, single-candle look.

• Choose the antique brass taper holder if you want a matched set of three slender holders with a warm, hand-forged look that owners rate highly.
• Choose the black iron flat star if you want a single low-profile, farmhouse-style holder for one taper candle.