StoreDeal.ai store
Shop
  • Deals
  • Deal checker
  • Black Friday
  • Buying guides
  • Brands
  • Stores
Travel
  • Flight deals
  • Hotel deals
Company
  • Research
  • Press
  • deal.ai apps
Black Friday 2026
  • Walmart
  • Best Buy
  • Target
  • TVs
  • Laptops
  • Headphones
  • Apple
  • Gaming
  • Vacuums
  • Kitchen
  • Toys
  • Smartwatches
  • Tablets
  • Furniture
  • Mattresses
© Deal.ai Inc.
TermsPrivacy
Deal.ai › Compare

Black Iron Flat Star Candle Holder vs Brass Candle Holder Flat Base

Buy the Black Iron Flat Star if you want a rustic, farmhouse look and a wide base that sits steady on a shelf or table. Buy the Brass Flat Base if you want a simple, hand-made piece in antiqued brass that disappears into a room and needs no assembly. The iron star is the more decorative of the two and the heavier-looking; the brass holder is plainer and warmer in tone. Both hold a single taper and are small accent pieces, so pick on style and finish rather than on durability claims.

  • Choose the Black Iron Flat Star if you want a rustic, star-shaped accent for a farmhouse or primitive room and don't mind a quick assembly.
  • Choose the Brass Flat Base if you want a quiet, hand-made antiqued brass holder that blends in and arrives ready to use.

Prices

  • Black Iron Flat Star Candle Holder: $3.95 at theoldefarmstead.com (last seen Nov 10)
  • Brass Candle Holder Flat Base: $27.00 at June Home Supply (last seen Nov 10)
  • Difference: the Black Iron Flat Star Candle Holder is $23.05 cheaper than the Brass Candle Holder Flat Base at the latest prices (Nov 10)
B
Black Iron Flat Star - Small Candle Holder For Taper Candles

Black Iron Flat Star Candle Holder

Black Iron Flat Star - Small Candle Holder For Taper Candles

$3.95at theoldefarmstead.comChecked 19 h ago
See all prices and details
Visit theoldefarmstead.com
Pros
  • Wide base keeps a taper steady
  • Rustic star shape suits farmhouse decor
  • Cast iron feels solid and heavy
  • Matte black hides scratches
Cons
  • Requires assembly
  • Iron can rust if kept damp
  • Decorative shape limits where it fits
B
Brass Candle Holder - Flat Base

Brass Candle Holder Flat Base

Brass Candle Holder - Flat Base

$27.00at June Home SupplyChecked 19 h ago
See all prices and details
Visit June Home Supply
Pros
  • Hand-made antiqued brass
  • No assembly needed
  • Understated look blends into any room
  • Brass can be polished or left to patina
Cons
  • Plain design offers less character
  • Brass tarnishes and needs polishing to stay bright
  • Smaller base is less stable on uneven surfaces

What separates them

Black Iron Flat Star Candle HolderBrass Candle Holder Flat Base
MaterialFlat cast iron with a matte black finishAntiqued brass, hand-made
Shape and styleStar silhouette, rustic and primitivePlain, understated flat base
AssemblyAssembly requiredNo assembly
Base footprintAbout 4-3/4 in wide at the baseFlat base, narrower footprint
Candle fitSingle taper cupSingle taper, flat base
Finish careMatte iron can show dust and needs occasional wipingBrass patinas over time and can be polished back
OriginNot statedMade in India

Price history

$30.00$2.49
Nov 1Nov 10
  • Black Iron Flat Star Candle Holder: lowest $2.49 on Nov 2 at eBay; $2.49 on Nov 10.
  • Brass Candle Holder Flat Base: lowest $30.00 on Nov 10 at Elizabeth Design.

Prices at every store

Black Iron Flat Star Candle Holder

  • theoldefarmstead.comNew

    In stock

    $3.95Checked 19 h ago
    Visit theoldefarmstead.com
  • The Village MerchantNew

    In stockReturn policy

    $3.99Checked 19 h ago
    Visit The Village Merchant
  • eBayNew

    In stock

    $2.49+ $3.89 shippingChecked 19 h ago
    Visit eBay
  • Country Village ShoppeNew

    Availability unknown

    $3.95Checked Nov 1
    Visit Country Village Shoppe

Store links may earn us a commission.

All 7 stores and price history →

Brass Candle Holder Flat Base

  • Elizabeth DesignNew

    In stock

    $30.00Checked 19 h ago
    Visit Elizabeth Design
  • June Home SupplyNew

    Availability unknownReturn policy

    $27.00Checked 19 h ago
    Visit June Home Supply
All 2 stores and price history →

Specs compared

SpecBlack Iron Flat Star Candle HolderBrass Candle Holder Flat Base
Candle TypeTaper—
Colorblack—
Primary MaterialIron—
Height1.5 in—
Depth0.88 in—
Width3.13 in—
Base Width4-3/4" wide at base—
MaterialFlat cast iron—
Candle Cupsingle taper cup—
LocationFree Standing—
SizeSmall—
StyleRustic/Primitive—
Show all 16 specsShow fewer specs
SpecBlack Iron Flat Star Candle HolderBrass Candle Holder Flat Base
FinishMatte—
ShapeStar—
ThemeRomantic—
Assembly RequiredYes—

Questions and answers

Which is better for a farmhouse or rustic table?
The Black Iron Flat Star. Its star shape and matte black finish fit farmhouse and primitive decor, and the wide base sits steady on a table.
Which one lasts longer?
Both are metal and should last for years indoors. Cast iron can rust if it stays damp, while brass tarnishes but can be polished back.
Is the brass holder worth stepping up to?
If you want a hand-made piece with no assembly and a quieter look, yes. If you want a decorative star, the iron holder is the better fit.
Do either need assembly?
The Black Iron Flat Star requires assembly. The Brass Flat Base arrives ready to use.
Will they fit standard taper candles?
Both take a single taper candle. Check the cup diameter on the iron holder if your tapers are unusually wide.
Which is more stable?
The Black Iron Flat Star, with its roughly 4-3/4 in base, is the steadier of the two on uneven surfaces.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

More comparisons

  • Antique Brass Taper Candle Holder vs Brass Candle Holder - Flat Base
  • Black Iron Flat Star - Small Candle Holder For Taper Candles vs Square Flat 5 Candle Holder
  • Flat Agate Stone Candle Holder vs Black Iron Flat Star - Small Candle Holder For Taper Candles
  • Antique Brass Taper Candle Holder vs Black Iron Flat Star - Small Candle Holder For Taper Candles

Buying guides that pick them

  • Best flat candle holders