Ascot Leather Ottoman vs Macy's Collyn Leather Ottoman

Buy the Ascot if you want a round leather ottoman that works as a footrest, extra seat or coffee table and will age into a patina. It is the better-made piece: full-grain pure-aniline Italian leather over a solid rubberwood frame, fully assembled, rated 4.9 from 84 owners. The Collyn is a smaller, taller, embossed top-grain ottoman built to match Macy's Collyn sofa and loveseat; owners call it well made and comfortable, but it needs minimal assembly and its leather is a step below full-grain.

• Choose the Ascot Leather Ottoman if you want a large round full-grain leather ottoman that arrives fully assembled and is meant to develop a vintage patina.
• Choose the Collyn ottoman if you own or plan to buy the matching Collyn sofa and loveseat and want an ottoman that matches them.