Which is better as a coffee table substitute?

The Gio. Its 38.75-inch round top gives more usable surface, and the 9.5-inch clearance leaves room for baskets or a tray. The Collyn is smaller and sits lower to the floor.

Which one has better leather?

The Gio. Owners repeatedly call its leather soft and true to the photos. The Collyn uses embossed top-grain leather, which is more textured and firmer.

Which fits a small living room?

The Collyn. At roughly 31 x 29 inches it takes up less floor space than the 38.75-inch round Gio, which one shopper found too large for their room.

Is the Gio worth stepping up to over the Collyn?

Yes for most people. You get a bigger top, a stated 250 lb capacity and a much larger record of satisfied owners. Pick the Collyn only if you want the matching set or a tighter footprint.

Which is easier to assemble?

Both are simple. The Collyn needs minimal assembly, and Gio owners describe assembly as easy.

Neither maker gives a warranty figure here. The Collyn's stapled and glued wood frame is built for daily seating, and the Gio's sturdy build and wood legs hold up well in owner reports.

Macy's Collyn Leather Ottoman vs Poly and Bark Gio Ottoman

The Poly and Bark Gio is the better pick for most shoppers. It is a round 38.75-inch ottoman in soft full-grain-style leather with a 250 lb weight capacity, a 9.5-inch clearance and a 4.9-star average across 430 ratings. The Macy's Collyn is a smaller 31-inch rectangular piece in embossed top-grain leather, built on a stapled and glued wood frame, and owners mainly praise it as a match for the Collyn sofa and loveseat. The Gio wins on leather feel, size and proven owner satisfaction; the Collyn wins on fitting into a set and a tighter footprint.

Choose the Macy's Collyn if you own or plan to buy the matching Collyn sofa or loveseat and want a rectangular ottoman that fits a smaller room.
Choose the Poly and Bark Gio if you want a round, roomy ottoman in softer leather that doubles as a coffee table with a tray and has a strong record with hundreds of owners.

Prices

Macy's Collyn Leather Ottoman: $379.00 at Macy's (last seen Nov 10)
Poly and Bark Gio Ottoman: $598.00 at Wayfair (last seen Nov 10)
Difference: the Macy's Collyn Leather Ottoman is $219.00 cheaper than the Poly and Bark Gio Ottoman at the latest prices (Nov 10)

	Macy's Collyn Leather Ottoman	Poly and Bark Gio Ottoman
Shape and footprint	Rectangular, about 31 x 29 inches	Round, 38.75 inches across
Height	19 inches	17 inches
Leather	Embossed top-grain with a fine hand feel	Soft leather owners call quality and true to the photos
Frame and build	Wood frame with staples, glue and reinforced blocks	Sturdy build with wood trim and legs, easy assembly
Weight capacity	Not stated	250 lb
Floor clearance	Low open base	9.5 inches, room for a tray or storage underneath
Matching set	Designed to pair with the Collyn sofa and loveseat	Stands alone; no matching collection
Owner feedback	Buyers call it well made and a good match for the couch	4.9 of 5 from 430 ratings; a few find it large or low

Spec	Macy's Collyn Leather Ottoman	Poly and Bark Gio Ottoman
Placement	Living Room	Living Room
Brand	—	Poly and Bark
Overall Product Dimensions	—	38.75"Diam. x 17"H
Clearance	—	9.5"
Country of Origin	—	Vietnam
Round	—	Yes
Weight Capacity	—	250# capacity
Height	—	17″ high

Macy's Collyn Leather Ottoman vs Poly and Bark Gio Ottoman

Prices

Macy's Collyn Leather Ottoman vs Poly and Bark Gio Ottoman

Prices

Macy's Collyn Leather Ottoman

Poly and Bark Gio Ottoman

What separates them

Price history

Prices at every store

Macy's Collyn Leather Ottoman

Poly and Bark Gio Ottoman

Specs compared

What reviewers say

Macy's Collyn Leather Ottoman

Poly and Bark Gio Ottoman

Questions and answers

Ask our shopping agent