Which is better for hot sleepers?

The Beautyrest. Its sateen cotton blend is sold as cooling, while the Eddie Bauer is brushed flannel built for warmth.

Which fits a thicker mattress?

The Eddie Bauer. It fits mattresses up to 18 inches deep; the Beautyrest tops out at 16 inches.

The Eddie Bauer has the edge on paper: preshrunk cotton and a fully elastic fitted sheet, plus a 4.6 rating from 5,400 buyers versus 3.9 from 2,300.

Is the Eddie Bauer worth the extra?

Its recent daily price was $27.73 to $36.29 as of November 2026, so it is often the cheaper set. It also rates higher, which makes it the easier pick on value.

Are either certified for safety?

Both are OEKO-TEX certified. The Eddie Bauer carries OEKO-TEX Standard 100 and is not tested on animals.

Do both come as 4-piece sets?

Yes. Both are 4-piece sets with deep pockets and machine wash care.

Beautyrest 600 Thread Count Cooling Sheet Set vs Eddie Bauer Flannel Sheet Set

Buy the Eddie Bauer Flannel Sheet Set for cold rooms and anyone who wants a snug, preshrunk cotton flannel fit on mattresses up to 18 inches deep. Buy the Beautyrest 600 Thread Count Cooling Cotton Sheet Set if you sleep hot and want a smooth sateen feel with a peached finish. The Eddie Bauer is the better-reviewed set (4.6 from 5,400 ratings vs 3.9 from 2,300) and its recent daily price ran from $27.73 on November 2, 2026 to $36.29 on November 4, 2026.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.