Which is warmer, the Bedsure or the Eddie Bauer?

The Eddie Bauer. It uses real down fill, which traps heat better than the Bedsure's polyester down alternative.

Which is better for allergies?

The Bedsure. Its synthetic fill has no feather dust, while down can bother people with dust or feather allergies.

Which is easier to wash?

The Bedsure. Down alternative washes and dries faster; down needs low heat and extra dryer time to fluff back up.

Do both come in King with three pieces?

Yes. Both are King sets with three pieces, and both are reversible.

Which has more shopper feedback?

The Bedsure, with 1,600 ratings against 122 for the Eddie Bauer. The Eddie Bauer's 4.6 average is slightly higher.

Is the Eddie Bauer worth the extra cost?

Only if you want real down warmth and a plaid look. If you sleep warm or have allergies, the Bedsure is the better value.

Bedsure Reversible Floral Comforter Set vs Eddie Bauer Edgewood Plaid Comforter Set

Buy the Bedsure if you want a soft, lightweight down-alternative comforter with a floral print on one side and a solid on the other, and you want to spend less. Buy the Eddie Bauer if you want real down fill and a classic plaid that reverses to a solid. The Bedsure is the safer pick for allergy sufferers and hot sleepers; the Eddie Bauer is the warmer, more traditional choice.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.