The Eddie Bauer. Its down fill holds heat better than the lightweight down alternative in the Truly Soft.

Which is better for a hot sleeper?

The Truly Soft. It is labeled lightweight and breathes more than a down comforter.

Which is easier to clean?

The Truly Soft. Down alternative usually goes in a home washer; down needs a large front-load machine or a professional cleaner.

Is the Eddie Bauer worth the extra money?

If you want down fill and a higher-rated set, yes. If you sleep warm or want a cheap spare, the Truly Soft is enough.

Which has better reviews?

The Eddie Bauer, 4.6 of 5 from 122 ratings versus 4.1 of 5 from 193 ratings for the Truly Soft.

Do both come as a 3-piece king set?

Yes. Both are king sets with three pieces, and both are reversible.

Truly Soft Everyday Reversible Comforter Set vs Eddie Bauer Edgewood Plaid Comforter Set

Buy the Truly Soft if you want a lightweight, low-cost king comforter for warm sleepers or a guest room. Buy the Eddie Bauer Edgewood if you want real down fill and a plaid look, and you don't mind paying more. The Truly Soft is the cheaper of the two at its listed price; check current prices at each store before you commit.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.