Better Homes & Gardens Cashmere Teak Candle vs Warm Tobacco Pipe Candle

Buy the Better Homes & Gardens Cashmere Teak if you want a large two-wick jar candle with a lid and a soft, woody-rose scent for a living room. Buy the Warm Tobacco Pipe if you prefer a smoky, suede-and-leather scent in soy wax and want a smaller single-wick candle or a matching spray, diffuser or melts. The BH&G candle has far more owner ratings and a frosted jar with a wood lid; the Warm Tobacco Pipe line scores slightly higher but on a much smaller base. Both are solid mid-range candles; the choice comes down to scent family and format.

• Choose the Better Homes & Gardens Cashmere Teak if you want a lidded two-wick jar candle with a warm cedar, rose and teak scent for a larger room.
• Choose the Warm Tobacco Pipe if you want a smoky tobacco, suede and leather scent in soy wax, or the same scent as a spray, diffuser or wax melts.