Goose Creek Warm & Welcome 3-Wick Candle vs Warm Tobacco Pipe Candle

Buy the Goose Creek Warm & Welcome if you want a sweet, cozy gourmand scent and a three-wick jar that throws fragrance across a room. Buy the Warm Tobacco Pipe if you prefer a dry, smoky, leather-and-woods scent and want a single-wick candle that burns about 33 hours. Both are soy wax and both rate 4.7, but the Goose Creek has far more owner feedback behind that score. The Goose Creek is the safer pick for a living room; the tobacco candle is the more distinctive pick for a den or study.

• Choose the Goose Creek Warm & Welcome if you want a warm vanilla, amber and marshmallow scent with three wicks for even, room-filling burn.
• Choose the Warm Tobacco Pipe if you want a smoky tobacco, suede and leather scent in a single-wick candle.