Beverley Women's 3-in-1 Waterproof Jacket vs Marmot Minimalist 3-in-1 Jacket

The Beverley is the warmer, more versatile pick: a 10K waterproof shell with taped seams and a detachable synthetic-filled inner jacket you can wear together or apart. The Marmot Minimalist 3-in-1 uses a 2.5-layer waterproof membrane, which packs lighter and breathes better on the move, but it carries less insulation detail and fewer stated specs. Owners of the Beverley rate it 4.7 from 663 ratings and praise its waterproofing and warmth; the common gripes are fiddly hood reattachment and long sleeves. Buy the Beverley for cold, wet everyday wear; buy the Marmot if you want a lighter hiking shell.

• Choose the Beverley if you want one coat for winter commuting and wet days, with a removable warm layer and taped seams.
• Choose the Marmot Minimalist 3-in-1 if you hike and want a lighter 2.5-layer shell that packs down and moves with you.