Columbia Amaze Puff 3-in-1 Jacket vs Beverley Women's 3-in-1 Waterproof Jacket
Buy the Columbia Amaze Puff if warmth and a light packable coat matter most: 650 fill power down traps more heat per ounce than the Beverley's synthetic fill, and the removable hood and roomy fit suit everyday winter wear. Buy the Beverley if you want a true rain shell: its 10K waterproof and 10K breathable ratings, taped seams and DWR coating are stated outright, while Columbia lists only a moisture-repelling finish. Owners rate the Beverley 4.7 from 663 ratings and praise its versatility, but some call it less warm than expected and report inner-jacket clasps popping off.
- Choose the Columbia Amaze Puff if you want a warmer, lighter everyday winter coat with down insulation and a hood you can take off.
- Choose the Beverley if you need a proven waterproof shell with taped seams and a zip-off hood, plus a separate inner puffer for milder days.
Prices
- Columbia Amaze Puff 3-in-1 Jacket: $220.00 at Backcountry (checked today)
- Beverley Women's 3-in-1 Waterproof Jacket: $215.00 at TOG24 (checked today)
- Difference: the Beverley Women's 3-in-1 Waterproof Jacket is $5.00 cheaper than the Columbia Amaze Puff 3-in-1 Jacket today

