Which is better for standing all day?

The Birkenstock Boston. Its cork footbed gives arch support and stability, while the Mellow Clog is soft foam with no stated arch support.

The Boston. Suede and cork wear slowly and the EVA outsole can be replaced. Foam clogs compress and cannot be repaired.

Is the Boston worth the extra money?

At $87.99 at eBay as of November 5, 2026, yes if you wear them often and want support. At the $157.81 high from November 3, the gap to $49.75 is hard to justify for casual use.

Which is better for wet weather or the garden?

The Crocs Mellow Clog. It rinses clean and dries fast, while suede on the Boston stains and holds water.

Do the Boston and the Mellow Clog fit the same?

No. The Boston has a buckled strap and comes in whole and half sizes at medium width. The Mellow Clog is a slip-on foam clog with no adjustment, so fit depends on the molded shell.

Which is lighter to travel with?

The Mellow Clog. It is a single-piece foam shoe, while the Boston pairs a suede upper with a cork footbed.

Birkenstock Boston Clog vs Crocs Mellow Clogs

Buy the Birkenstock Boston if you want a real suede upper, a cork footbed with arch support, and a shoe that can be resoled and worn for years. Buy the Crocs Mellow Clog if you want a soft, lightweight, easy-to-clean foam clog for around the house or quick errands. The Boston is the better long-term buy at $87.99 at eBay as of November 5, 2026, though it has ranged up to $157.81 since November 3. The Mellow Clog is $49.75 at Amazon as of November 5, 2026, and only one store lists it new.

Today the Crocs Mellow Clogs costs $38.24 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.