Which is better for all-day standing?

The Crocs Mellow Clog wins on pure cushioning with its deep, slow-rebound foam footbed. The Rothy's has firmer PU foam but adds arch support, which some people prefer for long days.

Is the Rothy's Casual Clog worth the extra money?

Only if you value the washable wool upper, the arch support and the dressier look. At $105.00 versus $49.75 as of November 5, 2026, you pay about $55 more for those.

Which one lasts longer?

The Rothy's knit upper and rubber outsole should hold up better over years of wear, and you can machine wash it. Crocs foam compresses and can wear down with heavy use.

Do the Rothy's clogs run true to size?

No. They run large, and Rothy's recommends sizing down a half size. The Crocs Mellow Clog fits roomy but true to size.

Can I wash the Crocs Mellow Clog?

No. Wipe them clean and let them air dry. The Rothy's Casual Clog is machine washable.

Which is better for wide feet?

Both are roomy. The Rothy's is described as just right in width, and the Crocs foam clog is roomy and forgiving, so wide feet often do well in either.

Rothy's The Casual Clog vs Crocs Mellow Clogs

Buy the Crocs Mellow Clog for deep, soft, sink-in cushioning at a much lower price. Buy the Rothy's Casual Clog if you want a machine-washable wool upper, added arch support and a dressier look. As of November 5, 2026, the Rothy's best new price is $105.00 at eBay, and the Crocs best new price is $49.75 at Amazon. That is roughly $55 apart, so the Crocs is the value pick and the Rothy's is the upgrade.

Today the Crocs Mellow Clogs costs $55.25 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.