Which is better for quick gray coverage?

The All-in-One Reusable Kit states 7 minutes for gray coverage. The shampoo lists a 20-minute full cure time, so the kit is faster.

The shampoo claims permanent color. The kit states up to 5 weeks, so the shampoo should outlast it before fading.

Is the kit worth the extra $13?

If you want faster coverage, a measured kit and about 4 applications, yes. If you want the lowest price and a permanent result, the shampoo is the better value.

Which is gentler on skin?

Both are ammonia free. The kit gives a 48-hour skin test instruction; the shampoo lists no skin test, so patch test on your own before first use.

Can I use either on both beard and hair?

The shampoo is marketed for beard, moustache and gray hair. The kit is sold as a hair and beard dye, so both cover facial hair and scalp hair.

How many uses do I get?

The kit averages 4 applications. The shampoo bottle is 16.9 fl oz but does not state a use count, so expect many applications from one bottle.

Ivory Natural Black Beard Color Shampoo vs Black Hair & Beard Dye for Men Kit

Buy the Black Beard Color Shampoo if you want the lowest cost and the simplest routine: one bottle, 16.9 fl oz, $16.91 at Amazon as of November 7, 2026. Buy the All-in-One Reusable Kit if you want a measured, reusable dye kit with a stated 7-minute gray coverage time and up to 5 weeks of color, at $29.95 at Nordstrom as of November 7, 2026. The shampoo costs about $13 less, but the kit gives more control over mixing and repeat applications.

Today the Ivory Natural Black Beard Color Shampoo costs $13.04 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.