Which set is better for a kitchen island?

Both are counter height, so either fits a standard 36-inch counter. The boucle set is softer to sit on; the acacia set gives you four seats and a higher weight limit.

Which lasts longer outdoors?

The acacia set. It is listed for patios and indoor/outdoor use, while the boucle and seagrass set is indoor only.

Is the 3-stool set worth the price?

At $668.97 at Amazon as of November 5, 2026, you pay about $223 per stool for upholstered seats and a woven back. Check the 4-stool set's live price to see the per-stool difference.

How many stools do I get?

The boucle set includes 3 stools. The acacia set includes 4.

Which is easier to assemble?

The boucle set lists 60 minutes. The acacia set lists 20 minutes in its specs but 80 minutes in its description, so expect up to about 80.

Which holds more weight?

The acacia set, at 300 lbs per stool versus 250 lbs for the boucle set.

Nathan James Beacon Counter Stool Set of 3 vs Wood Counter Height Bar Stools Light Brown (Set of 4)

Buy the boucle and seagrass set of 3 if you want a counter stool with a padded seat and a woven back for a coastal kitchen or dining counter. Buy the solid acacia set of 4 if you need four stools, a higher weight limit, or stools that can go outdoors. The 3-stool set is $668.97 at Amazon as of November 5, 2026; the 4-stool set has no price listed here, so compare its live price across stores before deciding.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.