Black FridayDealsBuying guidesBrandsStoresResearchTermsPrivacydeal.ai apps
Black Friday 2026:TVsLaptopsHeadphonesAppleGamingVacuumsKitchenToysSmartwatchesTabletsFurnitureMattresses

© Deal.ai Inc.

Deal.ai › Compare

Faux Leather and Metal Counter Height Bar Stools Brown (Set of 4) vs Nathan James Beacon Counter Stool Set of 3

Buy the Nathan James Dahlia set of 4 if you need four matching stools, a higher 25.9-inch seat, or a 300 lb weight limit. Buy the Beacon set of 3 if you want a solid wood frame and a natural seagrass back and only need three seats. The Beacon costs $668.97 at Amazon as of November 5, 2026; no current price was given for the Dahlia set of 4, so compare its listing price against that before deciding.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

F
Faux Leather and Metal Counter Height Bar Stools Brown (Set of 4)

Faux Leather and Metal Counter Height Bar Stools Brown (Set of 4)

4.9(131 ratings)

Choose the Dahlia set of 4 if you need four stools, a taller 25.9-inch seat for standard 36-inch counters, or a 300 lb per-stool limit.

Pros
  • Four stools in one set, so a four-seat counter is covered
  • 300 lb limit per stool
  • 25.9-inch seat height fits standard 36-inch counters
  • Faux leather wipes clean; upholstery tested to over 100,000 double rubs
  • Leg glides protect floors
  • Cons
    • About 100 minutes of assembly
    • Metal frame reads more modern than coastal
    • Seat depth is only 13.0 in
    • No height adjustment and no swivel
    B
    Boucle & Seagrass Counter Height Bar Stools Light Brown (Set of 3)

    Nathan James Beacon Counter Stool Set of 3

    Boucle & Seagrass Counter Height Bar Stools Light Brown (Set of 3)

    4.9(133 ratings)
    $668.97at AmazonObserved at 7:01 PM
    Visit store

    Choose the Beacon set of 3 if three stools cover your counter, you prefer a solid rubberwood frame and woven seagrass back, and you accept a 250 lb limit.

    Pros
    • Solid rubberwood frame
    • Deeper 16.75-inch seat
    • Seagrass and boucle give a warmer, coastal look
    • About 60 minutes to assemble
    • Fabric rated over 100,000 double rubs
    Cons
    • Only 3 stools per set
    • 250 lb limit per stool
    • Natural seagrass and wood vary in color and texture, so pieces won't match exactly
    • Fabric and woven back are harder to clean than faux leather
    • $668.97 at Amazon as of November 5, 2026, for three stools

    What separates them

    Faux Leather and Metal Counter Height Bar Stools Brown (Set of 4)Nathan James Beacon Counter Stool Set of 3
    Set size4 stools3 stools
    Seat height25.9 in24.5 in
    Frame materialMetalSolid rubberwood
    Seat and back materialFaux leather over foam, low backBoucle seat with woven seagrass back
    Weight limit per stool300 lbs250 lbs
    Seat depth13.0 in16.75 in
    Assembly timeAbout 100 minutesAbout 60 minutes
    CleaningWipe-clean faux leatherFabric seat and natural fibers need gentler care

    Price history

    • Faux Leather and Metal Counter Height Bar Stools Brown (Set of 4): lowest $208.56 on Nov 2 at Lowe's.
    • Nathan James Beacon Counter Stool Set of 3: lowest $668.97 on Nov 6 at Amazon.

    Prices at every store

    Faux Leather and Metal Counter Height Bar Stools Brown (Set of 4)

    • Nathan JamesCheck price at Nathan James
    • Home DepotCheck price at Home Depot
    • Lowe'sCheck price at Lowe's
    Prices and history →

    Nathan James Beacon Counter Stool Set of 3

    • Nathan JamesNew

      In stockReturn policy

      $809.97Observed at 7:01 PM
      Visit store
    • AmazonNew

      Availability unknown

      As an Amazon Associate, Deal.ai earns from qualifying purchases.

      $668.97Free shippingObserved at 7:01 PM
      Visit store
    All 2 stores and price history →

    Specs compared

    SpecFaux Leather and Metal Counter Height Bar Stools Brown (Set of 4)Nathan James Beacon Counter Stool Set of 3
    Seat Depth13.0'' (30" Bar Stool)16.75 inches
    UpholsteryYes (faux leather)Textured boucle upholstery
    Overall Width18.1 inches17.4 inches
    Overall Height36.5 inches39 inches
    Overall Length21.1 inches21.7 inches
    Seat Height25.9 inches24.5 inches
    Frame MaterialMetalSolid wood frame
    Fabric Durabilityover 100,000 double rubsover 100,000 double rubs
    Chair TypeBar stool—
    Adjustability HighlightsSwivel—
    Adjustable HeightNo—
    Weight Capacity300 lbs—
    Show all 34 specsShow fewer specs
    SpecFaux Leather and Metal Counter Height Bar Stools Brown (Set of 4)Nathan James Beacon Counter Stool Set of 3
    Depth18.9 in—
    Height33.26 in—
    Backrest Height9.5'' (30" Bar Stool)—
    Weight24.2 lbs—
    Safety Weight Limit300 lbs—
    StabilityLeg glides protect floors from scratches and sc…—
    Back SupportYes, Low Back—
    Seating MaterialFaux Leather—
    Seating PaddingCushioned, Foam—
    Seating Type

    What reviewers say

    Faux Leather and Metal Counter Height Bar Stools Brown (Set of 4)

    • 4.9 / 5131 ratings

    Rated 4.9 out of 5 from 131 ratings, owners largely report the stools look more expensive than they cost and hold up well in daily kitchen use.

    Pros
    • Sleek look that suits modern kitchens
    • Comfortable padded seat for meals and homework
    • Sturdy metal frame
    • Easy-to-clean upholstery
    Cons
    • Assembly takes time
    • Seat height limits where they fit
    • Backrest is short

    Nathan James Beacon Counter Stool Set of 3

    • 4.9 / 5133 ratings

    Buyers rate the set 4.9 out of 5 across 133 ratings, with praise for the look and sturdiness. Complaints center on assembly time and natural variation between pieces.

    What people mention
    • LookPraisedOwners say the boucle and seagrass mix looks high-end and fits coastal or modern rooms.
    • BuildPraisedBuyers describe the wood frame as sturdy and stable for everyday use.
    • ComfortPraisedThe padded boucle seat is called comfortable for meals and lingering.

    Questions and answers

    Which set is better for a four-person kitchen counter?
    The Dahlia set of 4, because it ships with four matching stools. The Beacon set has three, so you would need a second set or a fourth stool from elsewhere.
    Which stool is sturdier?
    The Dahlia has a 300 lb limit per stool against 250 lbs for the Beacon, and its metal frame takes more abuse. The Beacon's solid rubberwood frame is sturdy too, but the lower limit matters for heavier users.
    Which is easier to keep clean?
    The Dahlia. Faux leather wipes clean, while the Beacon's boucle seat and natural seagrass back need gentler care and can trap crumbs and spills.
    Is the Beacon worth its price?
    At $668.97 at Amazon as of November 5, 2026, you pay for a solid wood frame and natural materials across three stools. Check the Dahlia's current price for four before deciding; per stool, the comparison is what matters.
    Which seat height fits my counter?
    Both suit standard 36-inch counters: the Dahlia sits at 25.9 inches and the Beacon at 24.5 inches. The Dahlia gives about an inch and a half more legroom under the counter.
    Which is more comfortable for long sitting?
    The Beacon has the deeper seat at 16.75 inches versus 13.0 inches, which suits taller users. The Dahlia's foam cushion and low back give more support for leaning.

    More comparisons

    • Faux Leather and Metal Counter Height Bar Stools Brown (Set of 4) vs Vail Counter & Bar Stool
    • Vail Counter & Bar Stool vs Boucle & Seagrass Counter Height Bar Stools Light Brown (Set of 3)
    • Faux Leather and Metal Counter Height Bar Stools Brown (Set of 4) vs Wood Counter Height Bar Stools Light Brown (Set of 4)
    • Boucle & Seagrass Counter Height Bar Stools Light Brown (Set of 3) vs Wood Counter Height Bar Stools Light Brown (Set of 4)

    Buying guides that pick them

    • Best pub stools for home bars and kitchen counters
    • Best bar stools for kitchen counters
    Stool
    —
    Seating ShapeBucket Seat—
    SwivelNo—
    PortableYes—
    Intended UseResidential—
    Usage LocationIndoor, Outdoor—
    PaddingCushioned seat and back—
    Footrest AdjustabilityFixed—
    Filling MaterialFoam—
    Set QuantitySet of 4 bar stools—
    Upholstery MaterialFaux Leather—
    Set Size—Set of 3
    Backrest Material—Natural woven seagrass backrest
    Assembly
    Mixed
    Some find setup straightforward, while others say it takes close to the stated hour.