Which is better for a small apartment?

The BowFlex. Its base is 63 by 49 inches and it needs no plates or rack space. The B52 is a full rack that is hard to move once built.

Can the B52 replace a gym membership for heavy lifting?

Yes for most lifters. The J-hooks are rated to 1,000 lb and the safety arms to 800 lb static, so it handles squats and presses that the BowFlex's rod resistance cannot.

Is the BowFlex worth it at $899?

Yes if you want cable and rod training without plates. Its price hit $1,499.00 on November 4, 2026, so $899.00 at Johnson Fitness & Wellness is near its recent low.

Both use steel frames. The B52's 2x3-inch 14-gauge steel and 1,200 lb rating point to heavier-duty construction, while BowFlex rods can wear and are replaceable.

Do I need extra accessories for either?

The BowFlex ships with grips, a lat bar, a straight bar and an ab harness; the 310 and 410 lb rod upgrades cost extra. The B52 includes J-hooks, safety arms, dip bars and a landmine, but long-reach lat work may need more attachments.

Which is better for two people training together?

The B52, which supports up to three users at once with independent dual pulleys. The BowFlex is a single-station machine.

BowFlex Xtreme 2 SE Home Gym vs Major Fitness B52 Smith Machine

Buy the Major Fitness B52 if you want free-weight barbell work, a Smith machine and a rack in one footprint. Buy the BowFlex Xtreme 2 SE if you want a compact cable machine with low starting resistance and no plates to load. The B52 costs more: $1,119.99 at Amazon versus $899.00 at Johnson Fitness & Wellness, both as of November 5, 2026. The BowFlex price has swung between $899.00 and $1,499.00 in the past week, so watch it before buying.

Today the BowFlex Xtreme 2 SE Home Gym costs $220.99 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.