Which is better for building muscle at home?

The Marcy suits heavy barbell-style pressing and squats with plates. The BowFlex suits higher-rep cable work and isolation with fine weight steps. Pick based on whether you prefer plates or cables.

Which takes up less space?

The BowFlex. It measures 49 in wide by 63 in long, against 79 in by 79 in for the Marcy cage.

Is the BowFlex worth the extra $400?

If you want light starting resistance, 5 lb increments and a smaller footprint, yes. If you want to load plates and use a bench, the Marcy covers that for less.

Which has more resistance?

The BowFlex, at 210 lbs stock and up to 410 lbs with an accessory purchase. The Marcy's weight bar is rated to 300 lbs of plates.

Can I do light exercises on the Marcy?

Not easily. Its listed minimum resistance is 300 lbs, so light cable or isolation work is limited. The BowFlex starts at 5 lbs per side.

Which is easier to assemble?

The BowFlex is the simpler build with fewer large frame parts. The Marcy cage is taller and larger and needs more assembly time.

Marcy Smith Cage MWM-988 vs BowFlex Xtreme 2 SE Home Gym

Buy the BowFlex Xtreme 2 SE if you want smooth cable resistance with fine 5 lb steps and a compact footprint. Buy the Marcy Smith Cage MWM-988 if you want a barbell-style Smith machine with plate loading and a bench. The BowFlex is $899.00 at Johnson Fitness & Wellness as of November 5, 2026, and the Marcy is $499.99 at Academy Sports + Outdoors as of November 5, 2026. The BowFlex costs about $400 more, but its price has swung between $899.00 and $1,499.00 in the past week, so timing matters.

Today the Marcy Smith Cage MWM-988 costs $399.01 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.